Same-Sex Marriage in India: Progress Made, Challenges Remain

Authored by Saksham Saxena, a first-year legislation pupil pursuing B.A., LL.B. (Hons.) at Rajiv Gandhi Nationwide College of Legislation, Patiala

The wedding of two individuals of the identical intercourse or gender is called ‘same-sex marriage’, which can be popularly often known as homosexual marriage. Marriage between “same-sex {couples}” is legally carried out and recognised in 33 nations (nationally or in some jurisdictions) as of November 2023, with Estonia turning into the newest, the place same-sex marriages might be legalised from the first of January 2024. Even with the latest developments in LGBTQ+ rights, same-sex marriages are nonetheless neither recognised nor protected by legislation in India. That is primarily as a result of such weddings are usually not according to the well-established cultural norms and traditions of Indian tradition. Heterosexual marriages have been the acknowledged and customary norm for a few years. India is a democratic nation with a various inhabitants that works onerous to guard the values of justice and equality for all of its members. Nevertheless, the acceptance of same-sex marriage presents critical authorized and social points.

This weblog goals to discover the legislative developments, societal views, and historic background of homosexuality and same-sex marriage in India.

Similar-sex relationships in India are usually not a latest phenomenon as an alternative, homosexuality has had a protracted historical past. The subcontinent has had a protracted historical past of publicly recognising and even celebrating the number of human sexual expressions. Historical writings, paintings, and cultural practices that painting a extra inclusive and versatile view of sexual identities are clear examples of this realisation. There was an elaborate acceptance of a number of sorts of human connection in historical India, particularly within the Vedic period. A majority of these connections prolonged past heteronormative norms. One of many earliest holy books, the Rigveda, has strains that painting a wide range of relationships with out overtly criticising any of them. One other instance of how tradition accepts gender and sexual fluidity is the idea of Ardhanarishvara, a divine creature that mixes features of each male and female id.

Nonetheless, the course of social requirements modified all through a number of centuries. In the course of the Center Ages, attitudes concerning sexuality modified because of a number of circumstances, together with colonial influences, the codification of non secular beliefs, and shifting political environments. This transformation resulted within the marginalisation of identities that aren’t heteronormative in addition to the event of deeply rooted prejudices towards same-sex partnerships. Victorian morality and the Indian Penal Code, which was enacted in 1860, introduced strict morality to British colonial society. This led to the criminalization of “sexual relations towards the order of nature,” which in impact made consenting same-sex relationships unlawful. This was a turning level in historical past when the celebration and acceptance of various sexual orientations grew to become much less prevalent and homosexuality was related to hatred and suppression.

With the passage of time folks began to face up towards unjust legal guidelines equivalent to Part 377 of the Indian Penal Code which punished individuals who had gay relations, and with a number of such cases society has lastly began to just accept and accommodate the LGBTQ group, nonetheless, there exists many challenges in the best way of reaching a society that’s free and only for the LGBTQ group.

With regards to human and civil rights, many industrialized nations have welcomed same-sex marriage. For a very long time, third genders have endured gender discrimination. They’ve campaigned relentlessly for authorized acknowledgement of their rights. “Authorized safety” for homosexual partnerships on an equal footing with heterosexual {couples} is now required. The liberty to marry is ‘considered’ as a “human proper.” Nevertheless, the Supreme Court docket in Supriyo Chakraborty v Union of India held that there isn’t any basic proper to marry. Though, the Hon’ble Supreme Court docket’s determination in “Nationwide Authorized Providers Authority v. Union of India & Ors” was the primary try and formally recognise their gender and the essential rights that each one individuals get pleasure from no matter gender. 

Hindu scriptures outline marriage because the union of two souls. It’s essential to do not forget that gender is an attribute of the bodily physique, not the soul. The Hindu Marriage Act and different Hindu legal guidelines are primarily based on these writings. It’s essential to recognise that the Act doesn’t intention to in any method contradict the values contained within the sacred scriptures; reasonably, it’s merely a codification of Hindu legislation. Allow us to always remember that each particular person, no matter gender or some other function, deserves respect and compassion.

Consensual same-sex relationships had been made unlawful by Part 377 of the Indian Penal Code, which categorized them as “unnatural offences.” This standard legislation was applied in India beneath British colonial authority as a direct end result of Victorian morality. On September 6, 2018, the Indian Supreme Court docket unanimously overturned “Part 377 of the Indian Penal Code,” which made same-sex relationships between consenting adults unlawful. This was an infinite accomplishment for the LGBTQ inhabitants in India. A serious turning level within the historical past of sexual minority rights in India was reached with the ruling in “Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India & Ors.” This judgement ended the discrimination towards them by the state and society, which had lengthy compelled them to stay in disgrace. However the joyous incidence was solely the beginning of a sophisticated and multidimensional subject: the legalisation of same-sex marriage. As we commemorate the historic success of decriminalising same-sex partnerships, we additionally want to pay attention to the obstacles in the best way of realising inclusion and equality for all.

Just lately this 12 months, 20 petitions had been filed by same-sex {couples}, transgender people, and LGBTQIA+ activists. These petitions collectively challenged the provisions of the Particular Marriage Act 1954, Hindu Marriage Act 1955, and the Overseas Marriage Act 1969, the petitioners contended that these acts don’t recognise non-heterosexual marriages, which implies that there’s discrimination towards the LGBTQIA+group. The union authorities had expressed willingness to represent a committee to look at whether or not sure authorized rights could possibly be granted to same-sex {couples} and queer {couples} as effectively, with out authorized recognition of their relationship as a wedding. This was in response to a question raised by the court docket if sure government directions could possibly be issued to make sure that same-sex and queer {couples} have entry to welfare measures and social safety, equivalent to permission to open joint financial institution accounts, to call the companion as a nominee within the insurance coverage insurance policies, and many others.

The structure bench comprising CJI D.Y. Chandhachud, together with justices SK Kaul, PS Narasimha, SR Bhat, and Hima Kholi, heard the matter, and the listening to commenced on April 18, 2023, and the judgement was pronounced on October 17. The Supreme Court docket within the judgement refused to grant authorized recognition for queer marriages in India. The court docket highlighted that it’s a matter for the legislature to determine. However all of the judges on the bench agreed that the Union of India shall represent a committee to look at the rights and entitlements of individuals within the queer union with out authorized recognition of their relationship as a wedding. The court docket additionally unanimously held that queer {couples} have a proper to cohabit with none risk of violence, coercion or interference, however chorus from passing any instructions to formally recognise such relationships as marriages. Tens of thousands and thousands of LGBTQ Indians had been trying ahead to a contented conclusion, and the ruling dealt a critical blow to their desires. A number of activists are devastated that the court docket determined towards extending full marital rights to same-sex {couples}, although this was considered a probably historic step for LGBTQ rights within the nation. Then again, there may be nonetheless hope that issues will enhance sooner or later and that it will assist same-sex {couples} in India advance.

The difficulty of same-sex marriage is turning into increasingly necessary worldwide, and India may benefit from the nations which have accepted and allowed it. The LGBTQ+ group now has equal rights and protections because of the adoption of inclusive legal guidelines in nations together with the US, Canada, and quite a few European nations. India can study from their errors and transfer within the route of an analogous stance on same-sex unions. This may entail determining the right way to encourage a extra progressive and welcoming society by comprehending authorized frameworks, public opinion, and cultural acceptability.

Despite the fact that the choice upset lots of people, there may be nonetheless optimism that the federal government would give same-sex {couples} extra rights and fulfil its pledge to kind a committee to research the challenges they encounter, equivalent to getting ration playing cards and getting pension advantages, and many others. In conclusion, same-sex marriage continues to be a sophisticated and delicate subject in India. Even after homosexuality was decriminalised in 2018, same-sex marriages are nonetheless not legalised. Despite the fact that the Supreme Court docket’s determination in Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India was a significant step in the appropriate route, additional authorized change continues to be required earlier than same-sex {couples} get pleasure from equal rights and advantages. Sadly, prejudices and cultural attitudes nonetheless stand in the best way of same-sex marriage acceptability in India. India ought to take the worldwide motion for LGBTQ+ rights critically and work in direction of reaching equality and inclusion for all folks, no matter their sexual orientation or gender id. With a purpose to create a society that preserves these beliefs, we should endeavour to deal with everybody with respect and equity.

“Estonia Legalises Similar-Intercourse Marriage.” The Wire, https://www.thewire.in/lgbtqia/estonia-legalises-same-sex-marriage.

“Ardhanarishvara / Ardhnarishwar – When the Final Man Grew to become Half-Girl” (August 10, 2023) https://isha.sadhguru.org/in/en/knowledge/article/ardhanarishvara

“Supriyo and the Elementary Proper to Marry – Centre for Legislation &amp; Coverage Analysis” (Centre for Legislation & Coverage Analysis, November 6, 2023) <https://clpr.org.in/weblog/supriyo-and-the-fundamental-right-to-marry/> 

“Unpacking India’s Wrestle with Recognizing Similar-Intercourse Marriage” (International Voices, June 7, 2022) <https://globalvoices.org/2022/03/28/unpacking-indias-struggle-with-recognizing-same-sex-marriage/>

Supriyo v. Union of India, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1348

Sharma P and Legislation L, “No Authorized Assist For Queer Marriages In India.Time for Legislature To Determine | Supreme Court docket” (Dwell Legislation, October 17, 2023) https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/supreme-court-same-sex-marriage-equality-queer-couple-240341?infinitescroll=1

Jazeera A, “Unpacking Indian Supreme Court docket’s Verdict on Similar-Intercourse Marriage” (Al Jazeera, October 17, 2023) <https://www.aljazeera.com/options/2023/10/17/unpacking-indian-supreme-courts-verdict-on-same-sex-marriage#:~:textual content=Whereaspercent20thepercent20courtpercent20stoppedpercent20short,thepercent20samepercent20sexpercent20remainspercent20forbidden.>