Wednesday, July 23, 2025
Law And Order News
  • Home
  • Law and Legal
  • Military and Defense
  • International Conflict
  • Crimes
  • Constitution
  • Cyber Crimes
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Law and Legal
  • Military and Defense
  • International Conflict
  • Crimes
  • Constitution
  • Cyber Crimes
No Result
View All Result
Law And Order News
No Result
View All Result
Home International Conflict

A Rejoinder to Dr Cosmas Emeziem’s “Conflict of Laws and Diversity of Opinions—A View of The Nigerian Jurisdiction”

A Rejoinder to Dr Cosmas Emeziem’s “Conflict of Laws and Diversity of Opinions—A View of The Nigerian Jurisdiction”


image_print

On this weblog submit, I reply to a current critique by Dr. Cosmas Emeziem of a weblog submit co-authored by Dr. Abubakri Yekini and myself. Our submit celebrated the elevation of Justice H.A.O. Abiru to the Nigerian Supreme Courtroom and highlighted its significance for the event of Nigerian battle of legal guidelines.

Dr. Emeziem argues that institutional experience ought to be prioritised over particular person experience. He states, “[I]t is important to remain targeted on institutional capacities, experience and competence and learn how to improve them—as an alternative of individualized experience, which, although essential, are weak foundations for enduring authorized evolution and a dependable PIL regime.” He concludes that: “Thus, the concept that “an skilled in battle of legal guidelines is now on the Supreme Courtroom after a very long time”  is probably deceptive—particularly for individuals, companies, and buyers who might not know the inside workings of advanced authorized techniques corresponding to Nigeria.”

Yekini and I in our weblog submit , clearly acknowledged: “Nonetheless, this isn’t to recommend that Justice Abiru’s experience is proscribed to battle of legal guidelines, nor that different Nigerian judges don’t possess experience in battle of legal guidelines. The purpose being made is that his Lordship’s prominence as a judicial skilled in battle of legal guidelines in Nigeria is noteworthy.” [emphasis added]. The work of a choose is difficult, and lecturers ought to acknowledge and have fun their experience.

Celebrating judicial experience is useful. As an example, Dr. Mayela Celis on 24 November 2021 in a single weblog submit praised the appointment of Justice Loretta Ortiz Ahlf – a non-public worldwide regulation skilled – to the Mexican Supreme Courtroom. Celis concluded in her weblog submit that: “This appointment will definitely additional the information of Personal Worldwide Regulation and Human Rights on the Mexican Supreme Courtroom.”

It’s common for judges to specialise in sure authorized fields, particularly on the appellate stage. This specialization permits them to supply main judgments in related instances. That is notably true in widespread regulation jurisdictions, the place judges are identified for his or her particular person attributes and infrequently present separate selections, which may end up in a various vary of opinions even throughout the identical case. For instance, within the English case of Boys v Chaplin, the Home of Lords was unable to supply a coherent ratio decidendi because of differing opinions concerning the regulation relevant to torts when making use of English regulation to heads of damages.

In Sonnar (Nig) Ltd v Partenreedri MS Norwind (1987) 4 NWLR 520 at 544 Oputa JSC of the Nigerian Supreme Courtroom, though concurring, expressed a separate view that as a matter of public coverage, Nigerian courts “shouldn’t be too desperate to divest themselves of jurisdiction conferred on them by the Structure and by different legal guidelines just because events of their personal contracts selected a international discussion board.” Many different Nigerian judges have since adopted this particular person strategy taken by Oputa JSC, regardless of the vast majority of the Nigerian Supreme Courtroom in Sonnar unanimously, and repeatedly in Nika Fishing Firm Ltd v Lavina Company (2008) 16 NWLR 509, and Conoil Plc v Vitol SA (2018) 9 NWLR 463, expressing desire for the enforcement of a international jurisdiction clause, besides the place sturdy trigger is superior on the contrary. On this context, the affect of a person choose in decision-making in battle of legal guidelines can’t be undermined.

In England, former United Kingdom Supreme Courtroom Judges like Lord Collins and Lord Mance are famend for his or her experience in battle of legal guidelines. Certainly, Lord Collins’ educational prowess in battle of legal guidelines is internationally famend, as he is among the chief editors of the main widespread regulation textual content on the topic. Nonetheless, this isn’t to recommend that judges who will not be specialists in battle of legal guidelines can’t make vital contributions to the topic. As an example, Lord Goff, identified for his experience in unjust enrichment, considerably contributed to the precept of discussion board non conveniens, delivering the main judgment within the seminal case of Spiliada Maritime Corp v. Cansulex Ltd. The purpose being made is that judges’ specialization in a topic considerably enhances the standard of judicial selections, a truth that students ought to have fun.

The rise of worldwide industrial courts in Asia and the Center East, which resemble arbitral tribunals, underscores the significance of particular person judicial experience. These courts, together with these in Hong Kong, Singapore, Dubai, Qatar, Kazakhstan, and Abu Dhabi entice prime international judicial consultants to preside over and resolve instances, thereby instilling confidence in worldwide industrial events (Bookman 2021; Antonopoulou, 2023). As an example, Lord Collins a former non-permanent Member of the Hong Kong Courtroom of Ultimate Attraction, delivered the main judgment within the vital cross-border matter of Ryder Industries Ltd v Chan Shui Woo, with the settlement of all different judges on the panel.

Yekini and I acknowledged in our weblog submit, that Justice Abiru’s “dissenting opinion in Niger Aluminium Manufacturing Co. Ltd v Union Financial institution (2015) LPELR-26010(CA) 32-36 highlights his dedication to addressing battle of legal guidelines conditions even when the bulk view falls brief.” If the bench within the battle of legal guidelines case the place Justice Abiru dissented had been conversant with personal worldwide rules in Nigeria, a special end result may need been reached. That is essential within the context of the quite a few per incuriam selections by Nigerian appellate courts, which maintain that in inter-state issues, a State Excessive Courtroom can solely assume jurisdiction over a reason behind motion that arose inside its territory, no matter whether or not the defendant is current and/or prepared to undergo the court docket’s jurisdiction (Okoli and Oppong, Yekini, and Bamodu) . The important thing level is that having extra specialists in battle of legal guidelines in Nigerian courts will considerably improve the standard of justice supply in cross-border points.

In conclusion, whereas Justice H.A.O. Abiru will not be all the Nigerian Supreme Courtroom for battle of legal guidelines, there’s nothing mistaken with emphasizing and celebrating his specialization on this subject. Subsequently, I stand by my co-authored weblog submit and can proceed to focus on such experience.

 



Source link

Tags: ConflictCosmasDiversityEmeziemsJurisdictionLawsNigerianOpinionsARejoinderview
Previous Post

Reform’s Manifesto Commitments on Justice

Next Post

Can the Court of Last Resort, Be First to Deliver Justice: Analysing the ICC’s Arrest Warrant against Netanyahu

Related Posts

A Missed Opportunity: An International Law Perspective on the Final OEWG Report
International Conflict

A Missed Opportunity: An International Law Perspective on the Final OEWG Report

July 23, 2025
The World’s Highest Court Can’t Ignore the World’s Biggest Climate Culprit: Fossil Fuels – Center for International Environmental Law
International Conflict

The World’s Highest Court Can’t Ignore the World’s Biggest Climate Culprit: Fossil Fuels – Center for International Environmental Law

July 21, 2025
Announcements: CPP-CSHR Report on Sport, Human Rights and Climate Change; TALS Academy in Advanced Legal Research
International Conflict

Announcements: CPP-CSHR Report on Sport, Human Rights and Climate Change; TALS Academy in Advanced Legal Research

July 21, 2025
Trump’s “Tarifaço” Against Brazil: a Breach of the Non-Intervention Rule
International Conflict

Trump’s “Tarifaço” Against Brazil: a Breach of the Non-Intervention Rule

July 19, 2025
ICYMI: USDA Plan Calls for Stronger Enforcement of Agricultural Imports | Customs & International Trade Law Blog
International Conflict

ICYMI: USDA Plan Calls for Stronger Enforcement of Agricultural Imports | Customs & International Trade Law Blog

July 17, 2025
What is so ‘International’ about it? – Cambridge International Law Journal
International Conflict

What is so ‘International’ about it? – Cambridge International Law Journal

July 18, 2025
Next Post
Can the Court of Last Resort, Be First to Deliver Justice: Analysing the ICC’s Arrest Warrant against Netanyahu

Can the Court of Last Resort, Be First to Deliver Justice: Analysing the ICC’s Arrest Warrant against Netanyahu

Ukraine urges bondholders to accept markdown on more than $20bn of debt

Ukraine urges bondholders to accept markdown on more than $20bn of debt

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Justices take up disputes over terrorism damages suits and habeas filings – SCOTUSblog

Justices take up disputes over terrorism damages suits and habeas filings – SCOTUSblog

December 8, 2024
At Least Two Volunteer Church Staff Members Shot An Active Shooter and Stopped the Attack at Sunday Church Service

At Least Two Volunteer Church Staff Members Shot An Active Shooter and Stopped the Attack at Sunday Church Service

June 24, 2025
The Major Supreme Court Cases of 2024

The Major Supreme Court Cases of 2024

June 5, 2024
Allies struggle to work with US military in space operations, GAO finds

Allies struggle to work with US military in space operations, GAO finds

July 11, 2025
How Long Before Criminals Start Attacking Cops With Drones? | Crime in America.Net

How Long Before Criminals Start Attacking Cops With Drones? | Crime in America.Net

July 1, 2025
What are RAR days and do they work?

What are RAR days and do they work?

May 9, 2025
Man shot 8-year-old during road rage incident on Near South Side: officials

Man shot 8-year-old during road rage incident on Near South Side: officials

July 23, 2025
Top Biglaw Firm To Open An Office In Silicon Valley – Above the Law

Top Biglaw Firm To Open An Office In Silicon Valley – Above the Law

July 22, 2025
Today’s D Brief: Spy chief misleads; Ukraine status check; Modular-arms production; Marines leave LA; And a bit more…

Today’s D Brief: Spy chief misleads; Ukraine status check; Modular-arms production; Marines leave LA; And a bit more…

July 22, 2025
India And Russia Expand Defence Manufacturing Partnership: Beyond AK-203 To AK-19 And PPK-20

India And Russia Expand Defence Manufacturing Partnership: Beyond AK-203 To AK-19 And PPK-20

July 23, 2025
A Missed Opportunity: An International Law Perspective on the Final OEWG Report

A Missed Opportunity: An International Law Perspective on the Final OEWG Report

July 23, 2025
Is baby getting enough breastmilk? New device helps moms learn

Is baby getting enough breastmilk? New device helps moms learn

July 22, 2025
Law And Order News

Stay informed with Law and Order News, your go-to source for the latest updates and in-depth analysis on legal, law enforcement, and criminal justice topics. Join our engaged community of professionals and enthusiasts.

  • About Founder
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2024 Law And Order News.
Law And Order News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Law and Legal
  • Military and Defense
  • International Conflict
  • Crimes
  • Constitution
  • Cyber Crimes

Copyright © 2024 Law And Order News.
Law And Order News is not responsible for the content of external sites.