The Role of Motions for Discovery in Legal Cases

Any litigator will finally need to take care of motions to compel discovery (also called “motions for discovery”). Whereas each side have the appropriate to collect data by way of the invention course of, disputes on whether or not sure data needs to be disclosed to the opposite facet are inevitable. This is the reason motions for discovery are filed and argued. 

Right here, we discover in additional element the function of those motions in trendy litigation.

Whether or not you have to file or oppose a movement for discovery, Clio Duo may help you harness the facility of AI to scan giant units of paperwork and seize the important thing particulars you want. Wish to learn the way? Ebook a Clio Duo demo at present!

There are a number of explanation why you would possibly carry a movement for discovery, together with: 

Forcing the opposite facet to answer discovery requests; 
Offering further responses when the unique responses have been insufficient; or
Imposing a discovery proper you possess with or and not using a discovery request (for instance, the required Rule 26 preliminary disclosures in federal court docket). 

Motions for discovery are necessary for getting the court docket to implement discovery guidelines. Suppose the opposing social gathering will not be producing a witness for deposition, or they reply to your interrogatories with baseless objections and no substantive responses. A movement for discovery could also be the perfect route for getting the data you have to advance your consumer’s case.

It needs to be famous that not all discovery-related motions are motions for discovery. For instance, a movement for a protecting order could also be filed to guard your consumer from overly burdensome discovery or to maintain sure data confidential, similar to commerce secrets and techniques. The movement for discovery is just utilized in conditions the place you might be in search of data by way of the invention course of and the opposite facet will not be “enjoying ball”.

Varieties of data and proof sought in motions for discovery

To know the function of motions for discovery, we first want to know the kinds of discovery these motions search. From there, we’ll look at the correct scope of discovery and the way motions for discovery can check these limits.

Varieties of discovery:

The next are the three commonest kinds of discovery which can be the topics of motions for discovery.

1. Oral testimony (depositions)

Previous to trial, you should utilize depositions to acquire oral testimony from events and witnesses. For the reason that deponent’s solutions to the legal professional’s questions are beneath oath, you’ll be able to lock the deponent into their story and discover the opposing facet’s data and proof. As well as, you’ll be able to observe the deponent’s demeanor and method of conducting themselves earlier than they seem on the witness stand at trial.

If the opposite facet fails to supply a witness in response to your deposition discover, a movement to compel the deposition can be acceptable. In additional excessive circumstances, an individual could seem for his or her deposition however refuse to reply sure questions, or their legal professional may be overly obstructive. A movement to compel deposition testimony, specializing in particular areas of data, would possibly then be the correct path.

2. Written discovery responses

Written discovery responses usually come within the type of responses to interrogatories or requests for admission. By getting the opposing social gathering’s responses to questions, together with admissions or denials of key information and contentions, you’ll be able to slender the scope of the case and higher put together for trial.

Generally, a celebration could merely fail to answer written discovery. Even when a celebration responds, their responses could also be stuffed with objections and lack substantive responses. The substantive responses themselves should be evasive, even with out objections. In all of those eventualities, a movement for discovery could finally be essential to get the unwilling social gathering to adjust to their obligations.

3. Documentary or bodily proof

Requests for manufacturing are served to acquire or examine paperwork or bodily objects within the opposing facet’s possession. Within the trendy digital age, many of those paperwork shall be in digital type, making digital discovery (e-discovery) a key side of litigation. E-discovery typically requires extra in depth court docket supervision and oversight.

Doc productions are a major supply of discovery disputes. The responding social gathering will typically declare the requests are imprecise, irrelevant, or overly broad and intrusive. The propounding social gathering will search assurances that related paperwork aren’t being withheld. When the events can’t resolve their variations (as is commonly the case), the motions for discovery will fly.

Scope of discovery

Your submitting of motions to compel, and the invention course of itself, shall be constrained by the allowable scope of discovery.

The primary requirement is that discovery should solely search data that’s related to the case.
As well as, sure kinds of data are thought-about privileged and shielded from discovery.
Lastly, the requested discovery should not be overly burdensome in gentle of the scale and complexity of the case.

Position of attorneys in getting ready and submitting a movement for discovery

Attorneys who put together and file motions for discovery should be well-versed within the information of the case and the rationale the requested discovery is important. They have to additionally pay attention to the authorized bases for any objections made by the opposite facet. Lastly, they have to meet all of the procedural necessities for the movement.

One key requirement for motions for discovery is the meet-and-confer obligation. Previous to submitting the movement, you could usually meet and check with the opposite facet in an try and resolve the dispute with out court docket intervention. Since motions for discovery are filed after meet-and-confer efforts have failed, you need these efforts to be well-documented to help your argument on the movement listening to.

Course of for submitting a movement for discovery

The method of submitting a movement for discovery begins when the invention requests are first served and could be briefly summarized as follows:

Provoke discovery and evaluation responses. If you don’t obtain responses by the authorized deadline, or the responses are insufficient, proceed to the following step.

Meet and check with opposing counsel. Elevate your points with the opposite facet’s discovery responses in writing, together with the authorized foundation in your place the place relevant. Nevertheless, be cautious of counting on written communication alone, since many judges will wish to see efforts to resolve disputes carried out over the telephone or in individual.

File the movement for discovery if meet-and-confer efforts fail. The invention requests and responses (if any have been served) should usually be connected as reveals. Connect any proof of meet-and-confer efforts, similar to correspondence. 

Some jurisdictions could require a separate assertion of the invention responses in dispute, so test your jurisdiction’s guidelines fastidiously.

Widespread challenges and how one can overcome them

Navigating motions for discovery could be difficult. Thankfully, you’ll be able to anticipate and overcome these obstacles.

Lack of fine religion participation within the meet-and-confer course of

Though events are required to take part within the discovery meet-and-confer course of in good religion, this requirement is ceaselessly violated. Sadly, many attorneys will merely search to play video games and delay slightly than present substantive discovery responses. It’s your job to reveal you made all acceptable efforts to resolve the invention dispute and the opposing social gathering is at fault. 

Different litigation deadlines

Motions for discovery could be much more difficult to navigate late within the recreation or when you’re going through quite a few competing deadlines on the case—for instance, on the discovery cutoff date or proper earlier than trial. This is the reason you will need to ship your discovery early within the case and begin the meet-and-confer course of shortly after you identify {that a} movement for discovery is important.

Make use of the results for failing to adjust to discovery requests

What makes motions for discovery efficient is the results the court docket can impose on the shedding social gathering. These can embrace financial sanctions, evidentiary sanctions (the place sure kinds of proof aren’t allowed at trial), and even terminating sanctions (the place the case is dismissed or default judgment is entered in favor of 1 social gathering). Be sure to particularly ask the court docket to impose acceptable penalties so the opposing facet will sit up and take discover.

Ultimate ideas on submitting a movement for discovery

Motions for discovery are a important software for profitable litigation. They’re your major technique of holding the opposite facet’s ft to the fireplace once they fail to offer the data you want through the discovery course of. Observe the above tips to expertise success with these motions.

If you wish to successfully resolve discovery disputes, you will have all of your geese in a row with respect to paperwork and consumer communication. Use Clio Handle to prepare paperwork and collaborate with purchasers securely, so you could have the bandwidth to file profitable motions for discovery and win circumstances. Ebook a demo at present!

We revealed this weblog submit in February 2025. Final up to date: February 4, 2025.

Categorized in:
Uncategorized