The very first thing Sandra “Sandy” Hemme did after strolling out of jail in July 2024 — after spending 43 years behind bars — was go to her father. He was within the hospital battling kidney failure.
Ten days later, he was gone.
Hemme, now 65, had been held for against the law she stated she didn’t commit — the 1980 homicide of a girl in St. Joseph, about an hour north of Kansas Metropolis. In June 2024, a choose agreed. By then, she had misplaced many years together with her dad and mom, siblings and a younger little one.
Compounding the loss had been the formidable obstacles Hemme confronted whereas searching for to clear her identify in Missouri, a state the place authorized and political methods usually resist admitting error even within the face of overwhelming proof. Missouri is exclusive in that it solely permits direct innocence claims for these serving a demise sentence. Even after the choose’s order releasing Hemme, officers from the Missouri Lawyer Normal’s Workplace — recognized for aggressively opposing exonerations — fought to maintain her imprisoned. Advocates say the state’s high management has been hesitant to meaningfully reform the methods that saved her behind bars.
Nonetheless, Hemme took solace in being current for her father’s last days.
“It was a aid,” Hemme informed The Marshall Challenge – St. Louis in her solely interview up to now since being launched. “A burden was lifted.”
She needs she’d had extra days with him.
Patricia Jeschke, a library secretary, was found certain and asphyxiated on her bed room ground in St. Joseph on Nov. 13, 1980.
On Nov. 28, then-St. Joseph Police Division detective Steven Fueston visited Hemme at a state hospital the place she was on antipsychotic remedy, court docket paperwork present. Her identify surfaced whereas he was investigating an unrelated disturbance. Hemme informed Fueston she thought she caught a experience from Jeschke after leaving the hospital on Nov. 12 from a earlier keep. Ultimately, Fueston testified, he stopped questioning Hemme that day as a result of “she didn’t appear completely coherent.”
He returned a half a dozen extra instances. Every time, her story modified. Fueston stated he stopped pursuing Hemme as a lead as a result of he felt he wouldn’t get the reality from her.
Throughout an eighth interrogation with a special officer, Hemme confessed.
In the meantime, proof surfaced implicating one other one who tried to make use of a bank card belonging to Jeschke and was discovered with a pair of earrings that belonged to her. However that investigation got here to a halt. Many near the case believed it was as a result of it was Michael Holman — a St. Joseph Police Division officer.
The police chief on the time even eliminated an investigator from the case after he concluded Holman, not Hemme, dedicated the killing.
A choose sentenced Hemme to life with out parole after she pleaded responsible to killing Jeschke in April 1981. A brand new trial was ordered after Hemme withdrew her preliminary responsible plea, however she was convicted in a 1985 trial. This time, she was sentenced to life in jail with out the opportunity of parole for a minimum of 50 years.
Hemme started contacting the Innocence Challenge round 2006. Officers stated the group took her case in 2018.
In 2023, her legal professionals filed a 147-page petition in Livingston County Circuit Court docket detailing how they constructed their case. They had been capable of retrieve paperwork from the Jeschke homicide case and on Holman from the St. Joseph Police Division that had not been beforehand disclosed. No bodily proof ever linked Hemme to the crime. Psychiatrist Judith Edersheim concluded in an analysis that Hemme was at excessive threat for falsely confessing resulting from her critical psychological sickness and the antipsychotic remedy she had been placed on, which doubtless disrupted her cognitive pondering.
Sean O’Brien, a Kansas Metropolis-based legal professional who represented Hemme alongside Innocence Challenge attorneys, known as her case “a failure of all the things,” together with the St. Joseph police steering the investigation away from one among their very own.
Due to the state’s stance that solely these on demise row can convey innocence claims earlier than a court docket, Hemme’s attorneys alleged constitutional violations — together with that police hid proof of Holman as a greater suspect and that her earlier attorneys had been ineffective. It labored.
A court docket exhibit photograph confirmed the house the place Patricia Jeschke, the sufferer, lived and was discovered.
“It is not a declare that they will elevate in the event that they obtained another sentence, life with out parole or anything,” Bay Scoggin, a state coverage advocate with the Innocence Challenge, stated of the state’s mandate that these searching for to be freed have to be on demise row to obtain one other trial.
The loophole dates again to 2003 when O’Brien was representing Joe Amrine, who was on demise row. He was exonerated after the Missouri Supreme Court docket discovered clear and convincing proof of his innocence. Subsequent circumstances had been principally denied in the event that they lacked a demise sentence, till a 2021 legislation allowed prosecutors to file motions once they believed somebody was wrongfully convicted.
An FBI fingerprint report confirmed that Hemme’s fingerprints weren’t on the scene. Yellow highlighting added by The Marshall Challenge.
Altering the demise penalty requirement may occur via motion by the state Legislature or the Missouri Supreme Court docket, stated former Chief Justice Michael Wolff, who spent 13 years on the court docket earlier than retiring in 2011. The query was not introduced earlier than the court docket throughout his time, Wolff stated.
Bipartisan payments proposed this yr in Missouri’s Normal Meeting would permit somebody in jail to convey an innocence declare earlier than a choose, who would have the authority to vacate a conviction if convincing proof helps an individual’s innocence.
Throughout a joint listening to on the measures, officers from Missouri Lawyer Normal Andrew Bailey’s workplace voiced opposition.
“This invoice undermines the rule of legislation and is a miscarriage of justice,” First Assistant Lawyer Normal Jay Atkins stated throughout heated testimony in February earlier than the Judiciary Committee. “And what’s worse is, it’s doing it on the backs of victims.”
Rep. David Tyson Smith requested if reviewing some circumstances that turned out to be frivolous was value it if the invoice freed an harmless individual.
“You characterize the legal professional normal, and also you’re speaking about individuals who may doubtlessly be harmless, and also you’re coming in right here in nearly a hostile method speaking about miscarriage of justice,” Smith stated. “Frankly, I discover that’s disgusting, particularly if there’s people who find themselves really harmless.”
Hemme confronted related resistance by the Lawyer Normal’s Workplace all through her case. However in June 2024, Circuit Choose Ryan Horsman declared in a 118-page order that she was “the sufferer of a manifest injustice.” He added that the proof straight tied Holman, who died in 2015, to the homicide.
Horsman ordered her launch on July 9. She walked free 10 days later, delayed by interference from the Lawyer Normal’s Workplace, together with officers unsuccessfully submitting paperwork to disclaim the choice and calling the warden to dam her launch.
The legal professional normal’s resistance to Hemme’s innocence case didn’t come as a shock to many on the opposing aspect. The workplace has a observe report of disputing wrongful conviction claims, even when proof casts critical doubt on a verdict. That stance has endured below earlier leaders from each political events.
A spokesman for the workplace stated Bailey and assistant attorneys normal who labored on Hemme’s case weren’t obtainable for an interview.
Megan Crane, co-director of the MacArthur Justice Middle, a nonprofit civil rights agency, stated it looks like the Missouri Lawyer Normal’s Workplace “prioritizes finality over equity.”
Nicole Gorovsky, a St. Louis legal professional who labored within the workplace’s appellate division from 2001 to 2003 below Democratic Gov. Jay Nixon, stated she took the particular guidelines for prosecutors severely.
“The underlying rules are prosecutors are to hunt justice, not a win,” she stated.
However she agrees that newer attorneys normal in Missouri have fought innocence claims throughout the board.
Quinn O’Brien, an investigator who labored on Hemme’s case with the Innocence Challenge, stated she believes the angle within the Lawyer Normal’s Workplace “actually is that it’s OK to maintain an harmless individual in jail or execute an harmless individual as a result of they’re defending the rule of legislation.”
Questions concerning the guilt of a person on demise row got here to a head throughout court docket proceedings in St. Louis County in 2024. Marcellus “Khaliifah” Williams argued that his DNA was not on the knife utilized in a 1998 homicide. When native prosecutors intervened on his behalf and pushed to have him re-sentenced to life with out parole, officers from the legal professional normal’s workplace stepped in to dam the deal. Williams was executed on Sept. 24.
Bailey was elected to a second time period in November. Since then, he has continued combating wrongful convictions, together with an open enchantment in Christopher Dunn’s case asking the Missouri Supreme Court docket whether or not the legal professional normal’s workplace can battle the choice that vacated Dunn’s 1991 conviction. His launch in 2024, like Hemme’s, was briefly delayed after Bailey’s workplace intervened to dam it.
Hemme recalled strolling out of Chillicothe Correctional Middle in northwest Missouri.
“I let you know what, I used to be so lightheaded. I felt so mild that it was exhausting to elucidate,” she informed The Marshall Challenge – St. Louis. “I felt like I used to be flying via air. It was so nice.”
She stated she spent her first months residence catching up with relations and taking life gradual and straightforward. She additionally continued combating her case.
In October, she made the journey to Kansas Metropolis for a Court docket of Appeals case introduced by the legal professional normal’s workplace. Attorneys alleged the choose who set Hemme free had exceeded his authority. She calmly watched from the gallery because the judges listened to the proof.
The panel struck down the enchantment, clearing the trail for Hemme’s official exoneration, which got here in December.
Regardless of all that she has misplaced, Hemme quips that she is “blessed by the most effective and never tripping on the remaining.” For now, she has been dwelling together with her sister and brother-in-law in Higginsville, a city of about 5,000 individuals about 45 minutes east of Kansas Metropolis.
Ultimately, she desires a spot of her personal.
She is ineligible for Social Safety, having spent nearly all of her working years in jail. A legislation signed by Gov. Mike Kehoe on March 26 makes her eligible for $176 for day-after-day of wrongful incarceration. It repeals a provision that solely those that show their innocence via DNA testing qualify for cost. Underneath the brand new legislation, Hemme must hand over her proper to sue the state for damages and, as a result of funds are capped at $65,000 a yr, she must reside into her 100s to recoup what she could be owed.
Hemme has been capable of get pleasure from regular, on a regular basis aspects of life: celebrating Thanksgiving and Christmas, cheering on her Kansas Metropolis Chiefs and attending church on Sundays. Her religion, she stated, is one thing that has at all times been essential to her. She has additionally savored time together with her mother, who lives a few cities over, and enjoying together with her household’s canine, Fortunate.
Hemme has been dwelling together with her sister and brother-in-law in Higginsville, a city of about 5,000 individuals in north-central Missouri.
The colder winter months had been tougher as a result of she was usually caught inside. She likes being outdoors and having the ability to take little walks.
“It feels good to get on the market and stretch,” she stated, including that even going outside whereas in custody was traumatic as a result of so many individuals had been at all times round.
She’s turning into acquainted with new expertise — like her smartphone, pill and e-mail — and making new mates throughout actions like bingo on the native senior heart. On a latest Tuesday, individuals marked off their playing cards as they chatted about households round city and native eating places, a few of which had been unfamiliar to Hemme. She was happy when she received to go as much as a desk of prizes after profitable a spherical, selecting out a small blue and white checkered quilt.
In late February, she turned 65.
For a lot of, it’s a milestone that signifies the top of a profession. Hemme, although, is within the throes of quiet beginnings. She spent the day with a pal she created from the senior heart, and her sister baked an angel meals cake that night. That weekend, her grownup granddaughter took her out to eat. Hemme loved a hamburger and onion rings.
One factor that also weighs on her: Different doubtlessly harmless girls remaining in jail.
Hemme is one among 56 individuals who have been exonerated in Missouri since 1991, in accordance with the Nationwide Registry of Exonerations. They misplaced upwards of 780 years of freedom collectively.
“I hope individuals hold combating for them,” she stated.
:quality(70)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/archetype/T4SU6FOBXJBDVDEIE2CV2QJMFY.jpg?w=120&resize=120,86&ssl=1)
