Filed
12:00 p.m. EDT
10.18.2025
The company’s aggressive recruiting, together with a $50,000 signing bonus, is hurting staffing in native businesses.
Folks line as much as communicate with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement recruiters throughout a hiring occasion in Provo, Utah, in September 2025.
That is The Marshall Challenge’s Closing Argument publication, a weekly deep dive right into a key prison justice concern. Need this delivered to your inbox? Join future newsletters.
“Are you able to defend the homeland?”
“AMERICA NEEDS YOU.”
These are a few of the newest appeals in a months-long, multi-million-dollar recruitment marketing campaign by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to rent hundreds of recent brokers and help workers to speed up deportations nationwide.
As of September, the blitz gave the impression to be working — the company reported some 150,000 functions from potential brokers. Some new recruits are current faculty grads. Others need to change careers. However one group of individuals has emerged as each controversial and essentially the most coveted potential new ICE brokers: regulation enforcement officers already working for metropolis and state businesses.
A number of police chiefs and sheriffs have accused the federal company of making an attempt to poach their officers after ICE officers emailed them providing money incentives to go away their jobs in locations like Florida and New Hampshire.
A number of the emails from ICE look like particularly focusing on folks from businesses which have already agreed to deputize officers as part-time federal brokers to assist discover and detain undocumented immigrants.
“Somebody in Washington must lose their jobs over this, as a result of that is ridiculous,” Florida’s Brevard County Sheriff Wayne Ivey mentioned in August of the recruiting emails, which got here lower than two months after Ivey vowed to shoot folks ”graveyard lifeless” in protection of ICE officers.
Different Florida Sheriffs, together with Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd and Volusia County Sheriff Mike Chitwood, shared related sentiments with reporters over the summer time, stating that ICE officers used the info the sheriffs had freely shared to focus on their officers.
The federal authorities can also be focusing on recruits from police forces in so-called sanctuary cities. In Atlanta, the feds spent practically $1 million in a single week on an promoting marketing campaign designed to lure native regulation enforcement away from departments the place ICE says the officers are “ordered to face down whereas harmful illegals” roam free.
The federal blitz is making it more durable for native and state police businesses to recruit and retain sworn officers, an issue that has plagued regulation enforcement since earlier than the COVID pandemic. Three years in the past, my then-colleague Weihua Li and I chronicled how the continuing exodus from policing was a part of an general pattern of individuals dropping authorities jobs for entrepreneurship or extra profitable jobs within the personal sector.
Police chiefs and sheriffs advised us that they had been making an attempt all the things they may to get and hold good officers, together with providing money incentives, reducing coaching and training necessities, dropping age restrictions and even pushing to chill out citizenship necessities in some locations. Since then, different regulation enforcement leaders have known as recruitment and retention a very powerful problem dealing with the career except for violent crime.
Now they face stiff competitors from ICE recruiters, who can dangle extra perks than most metropolis and state businesses ever may — together with affords of as much as $50,000 in signing bonuses, one other $60,000 in tuition reimbursement and an additional 25% premium pay for some particular agent roles.
However the marketing campaign doesn’t look like working in all places. Simply this week, the San Francisco Police Division reported its largest recruitment surge up to now 5 years. And in Oakland, regulation enforcement leaders teamed up with the NAACP of their push to interchange the six officers, on common, that they’re dropping each month to retirement and different departures. It’s a tactic unlikely to see a parallel in federal businesses like ICE, which operates beneath a Division of Justice that has overtly discarded variety initiatives beneath the Trump administration.
The guarantees that ICE is utilizing to draw candidates should not universally interesting, both. An officer in San Diego advised the Washington Examiner that ICE’s monetary incentives weren’t price sufficient to go away their present function.
For starters, the $50,000 bonus is paid in $10,000 yearly increments and requires a five-year work dedication. And in states like California, the place an employment advert exhibits a pay vary of $49,000-$89,000 for ICE deportation officers, cops could make about the identical quantity working in their very own communities.
And a few businesses in California have provided higher incentives than ICE for brand spanking new hires. In 2023, the Alameda Police Division provided a $75,000 signing bonus to officers coming from different businesses, on prime of a six-figure beginning wage. The division nonetheless struggled to recruit.
Officers additionally could also be fascinated by extra than simply the cash, says Jim Burch, president of the Nationwide Policing Institute. Burch remembers a roundtable dialogue his group hosted for regulation enforcement leaders final 12 months in Phoenix. When recruitment and retention got here up, he mentioned, he was shocked to listen to that chiefs and sheriffs within the cities had extra hassle recruiting than their suburban counterparts, despite the fact that the bigger cities usually supply increased salaries.
What he discovered was that many officers most popular the smaller businesses, even when they paid much less, so long as the neighborhood and metropolis leaders had a monitor document of supporting regulation enforcement. Burch questions why officers who take pleasure in a lighter work tempo in a much less hectic surroundings would depart their jobs for the comparatively longer hours ICE brokers seem to work, probably dealing with extra violent encounters and intense outrage and protests.
Alternatively, Burch mentioned, ICE officers get to work in a spot the place they get unparalleled help from inside management and the Trump administration.
“I believe it’ll be attention-grabbing to return and have a look at this 10 years from now and see who took these jobs, what occurs to their careers long run and the place they find yourself,” Burch mentioned of the ICE recruitment.
