Erik and Lyle Menendez score major victory after judge rules resentencing bid can proceed

Erik and Lyle Menendez’s resentencing hearings can proceed, a Los Angeles choose dominated Friday –bringing the brothers a step nearer to freedom after 30 years behind bars.

Los Angeles County Superior Courtroom Decide Michael Jesic shot down the brand new district lawyer’s bid to withdraw the resentencing request in a serious victory for the pair, who have been convicted of murdering their dad and mom, Jose and Kitty Menendez, of their Beverly Hills residence in 1989.

“All the pieces you argued at this time is completely honest sport for the resentencing listening to subsequent Thursday,” Jesic stated.

On the listening to, District Legal professional Nathan Hochman blasted his predecessor George Gascón’s formal petition to resentence the brothers, who have been handed life in jail with out the potential for parole at ages 18 and 21 — calling the request an “insane” political ploy that ignored primary information.

The brothers’ lawyer Mark Garagos, nonetheless, ripped the DA’s assertion as nothing however a “canine and pony present” and condemned the prosecution for displaying grizzly crime-scene pictures with out warning the members of the family watching from the gallery.

“The DA has assiduously proven that he has no consideration for the victims,” Garagos stated.

In the long run, Jesic sided with Garagos, ruling that Hochman’s workplace had no legally legitimate purpose to yank Gascón’s petition.

The court docket is scheduled to make its last resolution on resentencing after hearings on April 17 and 18.

At these hearings, the brothers and their attorneys will attempt to persuade the court docket that they’ve been rehabilitated greater than three many years after murdering their rich dad and mom of their Malibu mansion, emphasizing the brothers’ declare that the killings have been in self-defense towards their very own dad and mom after years of sexual abuse.

Final October, the previous DA requested a choose to alter the brothers’ sentence to 50 years to life, which might make them instantly eligible for launch underneath California legislation as a result of they dedicated the crime after they have been youthful than 26.

Hochman submitted the movement to withdraw that request final month, saying he didn’t assist the brothers’ resentencing as a result of they’d not admitted to “lies” they instructed because the case unfolded about why they killed their dad and mom and didn’t “totally acknowledge, acknowledge, and settle for full duty” for his or her crime.

Even when the choose decides to not resentence Erik and Lyle, California Gov. Gavin Newsom should select to grant them clemency and permit them to depart jail on parole.

The state parole board is presently conducting its personal hearings and can ship its last suggestion in June.

Lyle and Erik Menendez grew to become family names in 1989 after they bought shotguns and killed José Menendez — a rich music producer — and his spouse Mary Louise “Kitty” in the lounge of their Malibu mansion.

The pair tried to cross the killings off as a mob hit and went on a spending spree with their dad and mom’ $8 million fortune earlier than they have been convicted of first-degree homicide after two high-profile trials within the 90s.

A 2024 Netflix documentary about their case put the brothers again within the highlight; the identical yr, the district lawyer’s workplace revealed new proof that they’d been molested, together with a letter from Erik to a cousin, dated earlier than the murders, describing the sexual abuse.