‘Perverse’ Incentives: How Local Governments Might Cash In on Trump’s Migrant Detention

That is The Marshall Undertaking’s Closing Argument publication, a weekly deep dive right into a key prison justice concern. Need this delivered to your inbox? Subscribe to future newsletters.

Simply earlier than the 2024 presidential election, Butler County Sheriff Richard Jones stated that if former President Donald Trump received, he would get again into the “deportation enterprise.” Now, the suburban Ohio sheriff has put aside 250 to 300 beds for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detainees — round a 3rd of Butler County Jail’s capability, in response to the Cincinnati Enquirer, and a boon to the county’s income.

Overwhelming proof reveals immigrants are much less prone to commit crime than folks born within the U.S. Sheriff Jones himself concedes that immigrants should not extra susceptible to crime. Nonetheless, he has echoed Trump’s immigration rhetoric and vowed to do his half to implement Trump’s plans to deport undocumented immigrants. “I imagine in Americans first. Those that have blood and sweat into this nation have fought for it, them first. These different nations aren’t first. We’re,” Jones advised WLWT.

The detention a part of the “deportation enterprise” might be a worthwhile one for Butler County. In 2024, the county remodeled $6.7 million renting jail beds to different native and federal authorities companies, together with the U.S. Marshals and the Bureau of Prisons. Even earlier than Trump’s re-election, Butler County budgeted for a rise in that income to an estimated $8.5 million in 2025, in response to the Journal-Information.

A county commissioner provided assist for the sheriff’s plans to hire extra beds to ICE: “Clearly, the extra prisoners we have now, the extra income it produces,” Commissioner Don Dixon stated.

Butler County isn’t the one entity that would see income rise with the deportation of immigrants.

Trump’s plans would require constructing a large nationwide infrastructure, together with facilities to detain folks awaiting deportation, contracts to supply meals and healthcare companies throughout their incarceration, and planes to fly them overseas.

The Biden administration has already laid the groundwork for deportations, by extending personal detention contracts. Nonetheless, Trump will face vital monetary, authorized and logistical limitations in constructing or increasing any type of deportation infrastructure. However even when he solely partially delivers on his guarantees, the monetary and human impacts might be vital.

Because the election, there was lots of consideration on what number of for-profit firms, particularly personal prisons, stand to rake in large earnings from mass deportations. Some have already seen their inventory costs skyrocket. However native governments can also help Trump, for each political and monetary causes.

As The New York Instances reported final month, it could be practically unattainable for Trump to execute his immigration plans with out cooperation from native legislation enforcement.

Native legislation enforcement officers can verify folks’s immigration statuses after an arrest and cross them alongside to federal officers. And The New Yorker lately described how the Trump administration would possibly make it so much more people who find themselves arrested domestically might face deportation proceedings.

The job of detaining immigrants, although, is the place native governments most clearly stand to revenue. County jails might hire beds to ICE, increasing detention capability. Native governments also can signal intergovernmental agreements to supply detention for ICE, after which subcontract to non-public firms to truly run the jails — basically performing as middlemen between personal jails and the federal authorities. That permits ICE to bypass guidelines about documentation and aggressive contracting, in response to a authorities report.

Native jails are the most typical kind of detention facility that ICE makes use of, in response to a current report from Vera, an advocacy group working to finish mass incarceration. These sorts of agreements exist already beneath the Biden administration, however may increase beneath Trump’s deportation plans.

A 2022 report from the Brennan Heart for Justice, a liberal public coverage institute, discovered that native governments generally use jail house to generate earnings, by constructing “jails which are greater than they want with the expectation of promoting the additional house.”

In some instances, immigrant detention is filling voids left by declining jail and jail populations.

In Louisiana, greater than a dozen amenities closed after the state handed legal guidelines lowering obligatory minimums and rising possibilities for parole. However some buildings had been rapidly repurposed to accommodate migrants. The advanced interaction between state, federal and native governments and likewise between private and non-private entities usually makes oversight and accountability troublesome, in response to Bloomberg Information. The journalistic investigation regarded particularly at Louisiana’s Winn Correctional Heart, which is run by the personal firm LaSalle Corrections.

“The Louisiana Division of Public Security and Corrections owns the power,” reporters at Bloomberg wrote. “The Winn Parish Sheriff’s Workplace leases the property from the state. The sheriff’s workplace then indicators a contract with the federal authorities to permit the power for use for ICE detainees. Lastly, LaSalle Corrections is subcontracted to deal with day-to-day operations.”

When attorneys with an advocacy group tried to get data to analyze troubling allegations of abuse, every company insisted another person was liable for preserving them.

Whereas such preparations might develop beneath Trump, there may be already an extended historical past of native jails taking part in a job in immigration detention. “The Migrant’s Jail,” a lately revealed ebook by Brianna Nofil, reveals how these practices stretch again to the 1920’s and ‘30’s. “By the tip of the twentieth century, sheriffs are funding metropolis emergency companies, shopping for new police applied sciences, and eliminating private property tax off of migrant incarceration income,” Nofil advised Princeton College Press.

The circumstances of these jails had been usually inhumane. Based on Nofil, in 1925, a grand jury discovered the scenario at a Galveston, Texas jail so horrible, it declared it “against the law in opposition to humanity.”

Issues with poor circumstances proceed as we speak. In August, Massachusetts Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Ed Markey wrote a letter to ICE and the Division of Homeland Safety, elevating issues about poor medical care and allegations of employees violence at Plymouth County Correctional Facility. However since then, the county has signed a brand new contract that greater than doubles the jail’s income, in response to The Boston Globe, “paying the sheriff’s workplace $215 per detainee per day.”

Some states have taken motion to restrict how a lot native governments can contract with ICE, however have met resistance for monetary causes. Illinois handed a legislation banning ICE detention in 2021, however two counties sued the state. In court docket data, Kankakee County Sheriff Michael Downey stated the county’s contract with ICE generated $16 million over 4 years, which paid for a lot of points of native authorities. Dropping the contract would result in a necessity to extend taxes, lower budgets and lay off employees, the sheriff testified. A federal choose dominated in opposition to the counties.

Stacy Suh, Program Director at Detention Watch Community, an advocacy group that opposes immigration detention, advised me that these sorts of incentives are perverse. She additionally argued that prisons and jails don’t at all times ship the roles or financial boons cities hope for.

“We’re very involved that this detention growth is occurring — each by way of native governments which are combating shrinking budgets, or personal jail firms that want to revenue,” Suh stated.