.
Many commentators declare that Islam doesn’t pose a menace of violence in america. Influencers equivalent to Tucker Carlson typically repeat this argument. Others, together with then-President Joe Biden and FBI Director Christopher Wray, have argued that white supremacists symbolize the first home menace.
.
But March alone noticed a number of terrorist assaults carried out by Muslims. In Austin, a terrorist wore a sweatshirt studying “Property of Allah” throughout an assault. In New York Metropolis, bomb throwers shouted “Allahu Akbar” whereas throwing a do-it-yourself shrapnel bomb. At Outdated Dominion College, a shooter additionally yelled “Allahu Akbar” and had beforehand been convicted of supporting ISIS. One other attacker, whose brother was a Hezbollah terrorist commander, focused Temple Israel in Michigan, and yet one more assault, involving three males of Iraqi origin, focused the U.S. embassy in Norway. The Austin, Outdated Dominion, and New York Metropolis bombers and the Michigan synagogueattackers have been additionally all foreign-born people who have been naturalized U.S. residents.
.
Terrorist assaults take many kinds. For instance, the January 2025 truck assault in New Orleans, with an ISIS flag on the truck, left 14 folks useless and 47 injured. However let’s focus the dialogue on one kind of assault that has been extensively studied: mass public shootings. Researchers outline a mass public capturing as an assault through which a perpetrator kills 4 or extra folks at one time in a public place, excluding crimes equivalent to gang fights or robberies.
.
Taking a look at all mass public shootings from 1998 by 2025 reveals a number of patterns. Muslims commit these crimes at a disproportionate fee. White males commit them at a fee beneath their share of the inhabitants. And most shooters specific no clear political ideology.
.
From January 1998 to December 2025, america skilled 108 mass public shootings by 111 shooters. Eight of these shooters have been Muslim – 7.2% of the entire. Throughout that very same interval, Muslims averaged about 0.4% of the U.S. inhabitants. In different phrases, their share of assaults was 18 instances their share of the inhabitants.
.
The assaults included these carried out by Sulejman Talovic in Salt Lake Metropolis in 2007; Nidal Malik Hasan at Fort Hood in 2009; Mohammod Youssuf Abdulazeez in Chattanooga in 2015; Omar Mateen in Orlando in 2016; Arcan Cetin in Burlington, Washington, in 2016; Ahmad Al Aliwi Alissa in Boulder, Colorado, in 2021; and Syed Rizwan Farook and Tashfeen Malik in San Bernardino, California, in 2015.
.
Against this, seven attackers – 6.5% of the entire – expressed white supremacist, neo-Nazi, or anti-immigrant views.
.
Some attackers described as anti-immigrant additionally expressed environmentalist motivations. For instance, the murderers in El Paso, Texas; Dayton, Ohio; and Buffalo, New York wrote about considerations that inhabitants development – notably amongst minorities – was harming the atmosphere. The El Paso killer wrote in his manifesto: “The decimation of the atmosphere is creating a large burden for future generations … The following logical step is to lower the variety of folks in America utilizing sources. If we are able to do away with sufficient folks, then our lifestyle can grow to be extra sustainable.” Equally, the Buffalo killer wrote: “There isn’t a Inexperienced future with by no means ending inhabitants development.” The Dayton assassin was additionally an environmentalist, a registered Democrat, who described himself on Twitter as a “leftist,” and was very upset that Ohio’s Republican senator didn’t assist the gun management he thought essential.
.
These attackers additionally described themselves as anti-capitalist, anti-conservative, and supportive of employee possession of the technique of manufacturing. Regardless of these claims, information media shops persistently label them broadly as right-wing extremists or white supremacists.
.
The media broadly repeats the Anti-Defamation League’s declare that each one extremist violence from 2022 to 2024 got here from right-wing perpetrators. But the ADL labels the 2022 Buffalo mass assassin right-wing just because he expressed racist views and excludes different attackers. These omitted embody Audrey Elizabeth Hale, who attacked the Covenant College in Nashville in 2023 after denouncing “white privilege” and threatening to “kill all you little crackers,” in addition to Robert Crimo, who killed seven folks in Highland Park in 2022 and expressed hostility towards Trump, and Connor Sturgeon, who killed 5 in Louisville after praising the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests and criticizing police violence and Trump.
.
Total, non-Center Jap whites make up about 64% of the U.S. inhabitants however account for roughly 55% of mass public shooters. Seven assaults concerned people of Center Jap origin – 6.4% of attackers – about 16 instances their share of the inhabitants. That makes Center Easterners probably the most disproportionate ethnic or racial group concerned in mass public shootings throughout this era. Blacks, Asians, and American Indians commit these assaults at barely increased charges than their shares of the inhabitants, whereas Hispanics commit them at considerably decrease charges – about 9% beneath their share of the inhabitants.
.
Even earlier than this month’s assaults, the proof confirmed that Muslims in america commit terrorism at a vastly disproportionate fee, although that doesn’t imply that each one and even most Muslims are a hazard. The info additionally contradict claims that whites or right-wing white supremacists pose the first terrorist menace. Trustworthy dialogue requires acknowledging the info on who commits these assaults somewhat than filtering it by political narratives about which threats are acceptable to debate. If policymakers and the general public need efficient prevention, they need to begin with a clear-eyed evaluation of the dangers somewhat than with wishful pondering.
John R. Lott, Jr., “The Terror Menace People Aren’t Supposed To Focus on,” Actual Clear Politics, March 17, 2026.
