Friday, May 23, 2025
Law And Order News
  • Home
  • Law and Legal
  • Military and Defense
  • International Conflict
  • Crimes
  • Constitution
  • Cyber Crimes
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Law and Legal
  • Military and Defense
  • International Conflict
  • Crimes
  • Constitution
  • Cyber Crimes
No Result
View All Result
Law And Order News
No Result
View All Result
Home Law and Legal

Can lawyers hold doctors accountable for wasting our time?

Can lawyers hold doctors accountable for wasting our time?



I’m mad as hell, and I’m not ready any longer! These have been the feelings expressed by a lawyer colleague of mine, Franklin, after his physician saved him ready for over two hours. “I ought to ship him a invoice for my wasted time,” he stated.

I’m certain many people have heard this one earlier than. However I doubt anybody has ever despatched a invoice to a doctor for time misplaced sitting across the ready room. What would occur if, say, a lawyer tried it? Why not? The regulation is not any stranger to landmark iconic instances, equivalent to Miranda rights upon arrest or Donoghue v. Stevenson, the long-lasting negligence icebreaker case the place a producer of ginger beer was held liable to a pub buyer who discovered a decomposed snail in her opaque beverage. The British courts awarded her damages along with simply saying “Yech!”

I feel we might all prefer to see a lawyer bringing forth a lawsuit in opposition to a health care provider, with the decide’s determination wanting one thing like this:

Impatient J.:

That is an motion for damages by Melvin Alvin, lawyer, in opposition to Dr. Arthur Coopersmith, dermatologist. The plaintiff alleges that he visited the workplaces of the great physician to take care of a boil which sprung up on his neck. He says the appointment was scheduled for 10:30 a.m. on the twenty third of June final, however that he was not seen by the physician till 12:45 p.m. He notes that the defendant physician met him for about 5 minutes, throughout which he prescribed some ointment. The plaintiff pleads that he mustn’t have been saved ready greater than two hours, for him “time is cash,” and accordingly, the subsequent day he despatched the physician a invoice for $1,000 representing two hours of his billable time.

I’ll word that on the graduation of this trial, the defendant requested that I recuse myself from listening to this case if I had ever been saved ready by a health care provider and didn’t prefer it. I denied the movement on the idea that though medical doctors have persistently wasted hours of my life maintaining me ready unnecessarily like an fool of their crowded disagreeable ready rooms, overcrowded with sufferers obsessive about their cellphones, it by no means actually bothered me. In spite of everything, I’m a decide of the regulation. I’m completely goal. Sure.

FACTS:

The great lawyer plaintiff Alvin, to whom I shall refer as Melvin, testified that he meant to spend the morning in query getting ready for a divorce trial. He anticipated to be seen as scheduled at 10:30 by the defendant physician Coopersmith, to whom I shall refer because the defendant. Melvin notes that he even known as the defendant’s workplace earlier than arriving to evaluate any attainable ready time and spoke to the receptionist, one Gladys, who stated, “The physician is busy seeing many sufferers. He’ll see you this morning. Ha ha! Most necessary, don’t neglect your medical health insurance data …”

ANALYSIS

Melvin argues a number of factors of regulation justifying his declare. His first level is that the defendant is chargeable for forcible confinement. True, the great lawyer might have picked up and left, however that boil on his neck was too irritating and he had no selection however to hold in there in that overcrowded disagreeable ready room till he was seen by the defendant, who was completely thoughtless of his sufferers’ time. I discover there was a transparent case of forcible confinement right here.

Melvin additionally argues that the defendant is chargeable for deliberately inflicting alarm and misery. He testified that round 10:54 he was getting agitated ready, and he requested Gladys to ask the defendant how for much longer he must wait earlier than being seen. He notes that Gladys replied, within the fashion of Charles Dickens’ Madame Defarge, “No person interrupts the physician. Ha ha.” She then went again to her knitting.

As well as, the poor plaintiff Melvin pleads legal responsibility in negligence. He claims that there was an obligation of care owing by the defendant physician to his sufferers to make them really feel good, not traumatized. He refers to some well-established case regulation noting that physicians have for hundreds of years systemically saved sufferers ready. He cites the long-lasting keep-waiting case going again to the times of Chaucer, The Man of Regulation v. the Physician, 31 C.C.C. (Court docket of Loopy Instances) p 113. This was an motion began by a lawyer, one William of Yorke, who throughout a pilgrimage to Canterbury got here down with a fever. He consulted his fellow pilgrim the physician, and he was saved ready for 5 hours earlier than being seen. The trial decide, one Lord Gerald, famous, “5 hours? That’s manner too lengthy to be seen and handled with leeches. The great lawyer mustn’t have needed to wait greater than minutes earlier than seeing a leach. A plague on the defendant.”

One other case cited was Robin of Loxley v. Sherwood Forest and Associates, 29 N.N.R. (Not Nottingham Reviews) p 311, the place the plaintiff efficiently sued a bunch of physicians for exhibiting up three hours late when making a home name to Robin Hood and his merry males. The decide, Little Arnold J., awarded Robin Hood a sum of 280 shillings, representing what he might have earned throughout this down time, stealing from the wealthy and giving to the poor.

This court docket finds Melvin had made out a case in opposition to the defendant on all of his arguments.

DAMAGES

The proof was that his declare for damages for time misplaced was clearly foreseeable. After ready about quarter-hour, the plaintiff Melvin instructed Gladys, “Hey, my billable time is $500 per hour … simply letting you already know. I’ll be again in a few minutes after I get a cup of espresso from Starbucks. My meter is working.”

I discover this proof credible and foreseeable.

DISPOSITION

There can be judgment for the plaintiff as claimed, together with authorized prices. This award is to be paid forthwith. No ready.

I can’t say we will see a court docket determination like this for some time. We could have to attend a bit.

Marcel Strigberger, after 40-plus years of practising civil litigation within the Toronto space, closed his regulation workplace and determined to proceed his humor writing and talking passions. His newest e-book is First, Let’s Kill the Lawyer Jokes: An Legal professional’s Irreverent Critical Have a look at the Authorized Universe. Go to MarcelsHumour.com and observe him at @MarcelsHumour on X, previously often called Twitter.

This column displays the opinions of the writer and never essentially the views of the ABA Journal—or the American Bar Affiliation.



Source link

Tags: AccountabledoctorsHoldlawyersTimewasting
Previous Post

Lawyer suspended after arguing cocaine enhanced his cognition

Next Post

Utah considers allowing law grads to choose apprenticeship rather than bar exam

Related Posts

Israel Supreme Court rules firing of security agency chief ‘unlawful’ amid political firestorm
Law and Legal

Israel Supreme Court rules firing of security agency chief ‘unlawful’ amid political firestorm

May 23, 2025
JOB POST: Associate – Indirect Tax Litigation & Advisory at Economic Laws Practice, Mumbai [2 – 4 Years PQE]: Apply Now!
Law and Legal

JOB POST: Associate – Indirect Tax Litigation & Advisory at Economic Laws Practice, Mumbai [2 – 4 Years PQE]: Apply Now!

May 22, 2025
8 Tax and Financial Planning Mistakes to Avoid When Becoming a Freelance Lawyer
Law and Legal

8 Tax and Financial Planning Mistakes to Avoid When Becoming a Freelance Lawyer

May 23, 2025
Texas man Sues Whataburger and Sonic for Serving Onions to Allergic Man – Law Blog
Law and Legal

Texas man Sues Whataburger and Sonic for Serving Onions to Allergic Man – Law Blog

May 22, 2025
What Does it Mean for a Criminal Case if the Defendant is Legally Incompetent and Has a Court-Appointed Guardian? – North Carolina Criminal Law
Law and Legal

What Does it Mean for a Criminal Case if the Defendant is Legally Incompetent and Has a Court-Appointed Guardian? – North Carolina Criminal Law

May 22, 2025
Towards Sustainable Labor Law Reform
Law and Legal

Towards Sustainable Labor Law Reform

May 22, 2025
Next Post
Utah considers allowing law grads to choose apprenticeship rather than bar exam

Utah considers allowing law grads to choose apprenticeship rather than bar exam

How to Not Talk Politics and Survive

How to Not Talk Politics and Survive

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
New Research: Do Armed Civilians Stop Active Shooters More Effectively Than Uniformed Police?

New Research: Do Armed Civilians Stop Active Shooters More Effectively Than Uniformed Police?

April 4, 2025
Concealed Carry Permit Holders Across the United States: 2024

Concealed Carry Permit Holders Across the United States: 2024

December 4, 2024
NJ dad beaten to death in front of teen daughter after confronting family friend, his son over alleged assault

NJ dad beaten to death in front of teen daughter after confronting family friend, his son over alleged assault

May 1, 2025
Three Legal Project Management Tips for More Profitable Flat Fees

Three Legal Project Management Tips for More Profitable Flat Fees

May 14, 2025
Let’s Stop Asking for Last Words of People About to Be Executed

Let’s Stop Asking for Last Words of People About to Be Executed

May 20, 2025
It Is What It Is — Can You Plead That in Court?

It Is What It Is — Can You Plead That in Court?

January 6, 2025
Bank of America Corp DE Cuts Holdings in iShares CMBS ETF (NYSEARCA:CMBS)

Bank of America Corp DE Cuts Holdings in iShares CMBS ETF (NYSEARCA:CMBS)

May 23, 2025
Renewed State Backlash Against the African Court: Tunisia is the Fifth State to Withdraw Individual and NGO Access

Renewed State Backlash Against the African Court: Tunisia is the Fifth State to Withdraw Individual and NGO Access

May 23, 2025
Revisiting the purpose of sentencing

Revisiting the purpose of sentencing

May 23, 2025
Israel Supreme Court rules firing of security agency chief ‘unlawful’ amid political firestorm

Israel Supreme Court rules firing of security agency chief ‘unlawful’ amid political firestorm

May 23, 2025
JOB POST: Associate – Indirect Tax Litigation & Advisory at Economic Laws Practice, Mumbai [2 – 4 Years PQE]: Apply Now!

JOB POST: Associate – Indirect Tax Litigation & Advisory at Economic Laws Practice, Mumbai [2 – 4 Years PQE]: Apply Now!

May 22, 2025
Boys, ages 13 and 16, charged with mugging man on Red Line near Chinatown

Boys, ages 13 and 16, charged with mugging man on Red Line near Chinatown

May 22, 2025
Law And Order News

Stay informed with Law and Order News, your go-to source for the latest updates and in-depth analysis on legal, law enforcement, and criminal justice topics. Join our engaged community of professionals and enthusiasts.

  • About Founder
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2024 Law And Order News.
Law And Order News is not responsible for the content of external sites.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Law and Legal
  • Military and Defense
  • International Conflict
  • Crimes
  • Constitution
  • Cyber Crimes

Copyright © 2024 Law And Order News.
Law And Order News is not responsible for the content of external sites.