Highlights
This text is offered as a YouTube podcast.
An inventory of cities specializing in present and previous prices of downgrading crime statistics.
Do mayors insist that their chiefs of police deliver down crime totals? Sure. Does that lead to supervisors telling officers to downgrade crimes? We merely have no idea if these are remoted or systemic points.
Every little thing throughout the legal justice system is downgraded (dropped prices, plea bargaining, time served in jail). It’s not simply a problem with crime statistics.
Allegations of downgrading crimes are completely different from routine variations in classification, reporting requirements, or officer or prosecutorial discretion.
Crime statistics usually are not a direct measure of crime. They’re a measure of what will get reported, recorded, and categorised as crime.
CrimeinAmerica.Web-Chat GPT’s “Prime 10 Sources for Crime in America” primarily based on major statistical sources with trusted secondary evaluation.
Questions
If 5 massive males encompass you in a park and let you know you should donate $50.00 for a charity, is the occasion a solicitation or theft (utilizing power or the specter of power)?
If somebody reveals you a bulge of their clothes that will or will not be a pistol and calls for cash, is it an armed theft?
You invite a pal over to your condominium for drinks. You’ve had intercourse beforehand. He calls for intercourse now, no matter your protests. Is that rape or tried rape?
The place I do know the solutions to my questions, if reported, it’s as much as the responding police officer to categorize these crimes within the official document primarily based on quite a lot of elements (e.g., the sufferer’s willingness to prosecute). When this occurs, it will possibly have a dramatic impact on crime counts.
The examples above illustrate choices law enforcement officials make 1000’s of occasions all year long, and the impression of these decisions on crime counts. There are further elements to contemplate, like the potential for supervisors downgrading crimes or eliminating them. Most violent crime victims know their offenders, which may result in confusion as to the main points of a criminal offense.
Sure, the FBI and state crime repositories provide definitions of crime that debate distinctive circumstances.
The query of counting crimes is extra complicated than most notice. Categorizing crimes is usually a judgment name, not essentially an effort to deceive.
Article
When law enforcement officials reply to my articles about crime, the pushback is commonly quick and constant:
“The numbers aren’t actual. We’re not reporting all the pieces.”
It’s a typical chorus, heard throughout jurisdictions of all sizes. And it’s not new, probably 80 % of law enforcement officials’ feedback when my articles tackle crime lead to claims that their cities are being disingenuous about crime knowledge.
An Instance?
Violent crime charges plunge in America’s large citiesAxios: Violent crime fell sharply throughout the biggest U.S. cities in early 2026, extending a nationwide decline that started after the pandemic-era crime spike.
Pirro ‘not shocked’ after DC officers positioned on depart amid crime stats probeThe Hill: Greater than a dozen Washington, D.C., law enforcement officials have been positioned on depart this week amid an inside investigation into the alleged manipulation of crime statistics, a improvement U.S. Lawyer for D.C. Jeanine Pirro stated on Thursday didn’t shock her.
The dynamics in Washington, D.C., exist in each metropolis within the nation. All cities need decrease crime. In case your mayor calls for lowered crime, there may be strain to ship.
Proof?
First, there may be little onerous proof that the majority, if any, cities are taking part in quick and free with their crime knowledge; most are solely allegations. And it might take a a lot bigger article to debate all the problems with crime knowledge. For extra, see Is FBI Information A Dependable Depend Of Nationwide Crime?
Do I believe my police officer respondents are being lower than sincere? No, however it’s a matter of proof. Nevertheless it’s greater than a bit disturbing when a whole bunch of law enforcement officials, over time, are singing the identical tune.
Chicago
A long time in the past, after I left regulation enforcement and entered school, one in every of my first criminology programs examined Chicago’s historical past of manipulating crime statistics. It wasn’t offered as a fringe principle; it was a part of the tutorial dialogue about how crime knowledge is produced.
That historical past nonetheless shapes in the present day’s debate. However the problem has developed.
There is no such thing as a official record of cities confirmed to be downplaying crime. What exists as a substitute is one thing broader: a sample of allegations, audits, reporting gaps, and knowledge inconsistencies throughout a number of jurisdictions, previous and current.
Is US Crime Up Or Down?
Crime statistics for the US add to the confusion. Infinite mayors, advocates, and authorities officers are claiming that their interventions lowered crime in 2025 and 2026, whatever the lack of impartial, well-researched, and replicated proof.
The FBI states that violent and property crimes have decreased starting in 2023 (3 %) and 2024 (4.5 %). The most recent knowledge from the FBI’s web site states that crime continues to fall.
However per the USDOJ’s Bureau of Justice Statistics 50-year-old Nationwide Crime Victimization Survey (what the US Census and USDOJ name the premier methodology of counting crimes in America), we had a big enhance in charges of violent crime in 2022 (44 %), and charges have remained nearly unchanged for 2023 and the latest-most current full report for 2024.
The Nationwide Crime Victimization Survey states that city violence elevated in its newest 2024 report. Unbiased analysts say that violent and property crimes are falling significantly in cities primarily based on crimes reported to regulation enforcement.
Thus, any evaluation of things that contribute to violent or property crime is confounded by our wrestle to evaluate the effectiveness of interventions or to judge our private security. If we are able to’t agree on whether or not crime is up or down regionally or nationally, how can we decide the effectiveness of applications?
You may make any case about crime you need primarily based on USDOJ knowledge. Totally different sources permit for differing interpretations.
Concern Of Crime
Then we have to acknowledge that the overwhelming majority of the American public expresses an extreme or reasonable concern or worry of crime. Nevertheless, these expressing the very best ranges of concern have been lowered from earlier document fears.
Regardless, the excessive stage of worry comes from quite a lot of elements, together with private interactions with crime or the experiences of pals and neighbors.
The Majority Of Crime Is Not Reported
Nearly all of all crime just isn’t reported to regulation enforcement. Roughly 30 % of property crimes are reported, and property crime makes up roughly 70 % of all crime. About half of violent crimes are reported, in accordance with the Bureau of Justice Statistics. There are 120 million porch package deal thefts within the US. The survey indicated that there are much more porch-pirate thefts than the overall variety of property crimes reported to the FBI. There are various further examples I might present. The Bureau of Justice Statistics states that 13 % of sexual assaults are reported in city areas.
So, Earlier than We Look At Particular person Cities, Let’s Summarize
How law enforcement officials document crimes, how crimes are counted regionally and nationally, understanding that almost all of crime just isn’t reported, most violent crimes embrace somebody the victims know, and the worry of crime that the majority Individuals proceed to specific are all elements that make this dialogue difficult.
There are points with the FBI’s new Nationwide Incident-Primarily based Reporting System (NIBRS), which may document as much as 10 crimes per incident slightly than a single main crime beneath the earlier Abstract Reporting System. Roughly 16,000 out of 18,000 regulation enforcement businesses actively report knowledge to the NIBRS. There could also be points with full compliance as a result of course of’s newness. Police businesses will not be sharing all crimes that happen inside an incident.
We all know that a number of prices include most arrests that “might” simply double or triple a metropolis’s crime numbers.
The place Did I Get My Examples?
I used three sources for this text: media articles, ChatGPT, and Google AI. Format and displays will differ relying on how the information was offered.
Per ChatGPT:
Washington, D.C.: A Present, Excessive-Degree Investigation
Washington, D.C., represents essentially the most vital ongoing case involving the alleged manipulation of crime statistics.
Current developments embrace:
13 officers, many in senior management roles, have been positioned on depart or going through termination
Investigators are figuring out greater than 150 probably misclassified crime experiences
Federal and congressional scrutiny into whether or not crimes have been downgraded to current decrease crime ranges
No legal prices filed up to now
Sources:
Washington Submit reporting:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2026/05/05/dc-police-crime-statistics-investigation/
https://www.washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2026/05/06/dc-crime-stats-investigation-terminations/
Related Press:
https://apnews.com/article/47e615ad29b713953088d50877a2152c
Context:
Not like older instances, Washington, D.C. is present, lively, and unresolved, with vital management penalties.
Oakland: Fashionable Information Issues and Reporting Gaps
Oakland represents a extra up to date model of the problem—much less about confirmed manipulation and extra about knowledge accuracy and completeness.
Current reporting has discovered:
Crime knowledge submitted by Oakland didn’t match different official datasets, creating discrepancies
Errors have been vital sufficient to distort statewide California crime statistics
Inside acknowledgments that not all crimes could also be recorded because of delays and backlogs
Sources:
ABC7 Information investigation:
https://abc7news.com/submit/oakland-crime-opd-police-murder-robbery-doj/15498444/
Governing evaluation:
https://www.governing.com/management-and-administration/oakland-overstates-reductions-in-crime-due-to-faulty-data
San Francisco Chronicle reporting:
https://www.sfchronicle.com/crime/article/crime-state-california-data-20405949.php
Context:
Oakland illustrates how trendy reporting methods can nonetheless produce deceptive outcomes by way of error, delay, or inconsistency.
Chicago: A Longstanding Instance
Chicago stays essentially the most continuously cited instance in discussions of crime knowledge manipulation.
Investigations and audits—some relationship again many years—have discovered:
Crimes are typically downgraded to much less critical classes
Classification practices that would affect reported traits
Allegations from officers about strain to supply favorable statistics
These findings have been broadly mentioned in educational and media analyses.
Supply:
Crime in Chicago (abstract of audits and reporting points):
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_Chicago
Context:
A lot of this analysis just isn’t current. However Chicago continues to be cited as a result of it established a central concern: Crime statistics will be formed by how crimes are categorised.
Baltimore: Ongoing Considerations, Restricted Current Findings
Baltimore is commonly talked about alongside Chicago, although the character of the problem is completely different.
Reasonably than definitive findings of manipulation, Baltimore has been related to:
Longstanding issues about reporting practices
Broader debates about knowledge reliability and transparency
Participation in nationwide reporting methods which have skilled vital gaps
Supply:
Nationwide reporting points affecting a number of jurisdictions:
https://www.nssf.org/articles/america-has-a-crime-reporting-problem/
Context:
As with Chicago, a lot of the scrutiny just isn’t current. However Baltimore stays a part of the dialog as a result of it displays a broader problem: Inconsistent reporting can distort public understanding even with out confirmed manipulation.
New York: When Lacking Information Turns into the Concern
In New York, the priority has not primarily been manipulation, however incomplete reporting.
In some current reporting cycles:
A considerable portion of businesses did not submit crime knowledge to the FBI
This created gaps in statewide and nationwide crime statistics
Supply:
Nationwide reporting participation points:
https://www.nssf.org/articles/america-has-a-crime-reporting-problem/
Context:
Even with out manipulation, lacking knowledge can considerably distort crime traits.
Los Angeles, Philadelphia, Atlanta: Recurring Allegations
Cities akin to Los Angeles, Philadelphia, and Atlanta continuously seem in broader discussions about crime knowledge.
These conversations usually contain:
Disputes over whether or not reported crime declines mirror actuality
Questions on classification practices
Skepticism from officers, unions, or analysts
These instances are usually episodic and debated, slightly than confirmed by way of formal audits.
Google AI
Wichita, Kansas:
In 2023, allegations emerged that town’s reported violent crime knowledge was skewed, with investigations suggesting that the FBI’s Crime Information Explorer missed almost half of the violent crimes recorded by the native police division because of points with the brand new NIBRS reporting system.
Los Angeles, CA: Between 2005 and 2012, the Los Angeles Police Division misclassified roughly 14,000 critical assaults as minor offenses, in accordance with a Los Angeles Instances investigation.
Milwaukee, WI: In 2012, a Journal-Sentinel report uncovered that greater than 500 critical assaults had been misclassified as minor offenses. An inside audit later discovered over 5,300 underreported aggravated assaults relationship again to 2006.
New Orleans, LA: In April 2024, the division admitted it had underreported greater than 400 rape instances between 2021 and 2022, attributing the error to technical points with its document administration system.
Columbus, OH: After touting a drop in violent crime in 2013 and 2014, experiences in 2024 revealed that violent crime truly rose throughout these years, suggesting the preliminary victory claims have been primarily based on inaccurate knowledge.
Detroit, MI: A 2001 investigation revealed that the Detroit Police Division had erroneously excessive rape arrest statistics that skewed nationwide numbers, reflecting historic points with knowledge accuracy within the metropolis.
The Bigger Sample: Previous Findings, Present Considerations
Taken collectively, these cities illustrate a constant sample:
Chicago: classification practices influencing statistics
Baltimore: longstanding issues about reliability
Oakland: trendy knowledge errors and inconsistencies
New York: incomplete reporting
Different cities: recurring allegations, skepticism, and NIBRS compliance.
Washington, D.C.: lively investigation and management fallout.
The main points fluctuate. The timeframes differ. However the core problem stays the identical.
Why Officers Preserve Saying It
When officers say, “we’re not reporting all of the crime,” they could be referring to:
Incidents that by no means turn out to be formal experiences
Crimes categorised in a different way than anticipated
Backlogs are delaying entry into official methods
Administrative pressures—actual or perceived
This doesn’t robotically imply misconduct. Nevertheless it does level to a basic actuality: Crime statistics usually are not a direct measure of crime. They’re a measure of what will get reported, recorded, and categorised as crime.
Backside Line
There is no such thing as a definitive record of cities with confirmed crime downgrading. However throughout Chicago, Baltimore, Oakland, New York, Los Angeles, Philadelphia, Atlanta, and Washington, D.C., the identical points seem in several varieties:
Misclassification
Lacking knowledge
Reporting delays
Disputed interpretations
And maybe most vital: The idea that crime is underreported just isn’t confined to 1 metropolis or one period. It’s a longstanding, nationwide concern—voiced repeatedly by these contained in the system itself.
Abstract-Every little thing Is Downgraded
Every little thing throughout the legal justice system is downgraded. It’s not simply a problem with crime statistics.
City prosecutors don’t prosecute 20-30 % of legal prices primarily based on older knowledge from the Bureau of Justice Statistics. Newer federal courtroom knowledge counsel that fifty % of some crimes usually are not prosecuted.
Effectively over 90 % of legal prices are plea bargained. Charged robberies turn out to be aggravated assaults, leading to lighter or lowered sentences. This leads to time served in state prisons turning into a median of 1 to three years primarily based on Bureau of Justice Statistics knowledge.
So if my police officer feedback suggesting that their businesses downgrade crimes are right, it might match a sample that exists all through the justice system.
Lastly, I’m not suggesting a nationwide effort on the a part of regulation enforcement to deceive. Most (not all) cities all through the nation are reporting decreases in reported crime. If this can be a conspiracy to downgrade crimes, it might be too huge to cover. The precise statistics might differ, however the pattern primarily based on reported crimes is obvious.
Do mayors insist that their chiefs of police deliver down crime totals? Sure. Does that lead to supervisors telling officers to downgrade crimes? We merely have no idea if these are remoted or systemic points. Nevertheless it appears to be well-documented and taking place in Washington, D.C., so it might be taking place in different cities beneath related pressures.
ChatGPT And Google AI
ChatGPT and Google AI supplied sources. ChatGPT fact-checked this text.
Privateness Coverage
We don’t accumulate your private data. See our privateness coverage at “About This Web site.”
See Extra
See extra articles on crime and justice at Crime in America.
Most Harmful Cities/States/International locations at Most Harmful Cities.
US Crime Charges at Nationwide Crime Charges.
Nationwide Offender Recidivism Charges at Offender Recidivism.
The Crime in America.Web RSS feed (https://crimeinamerica.internet/?feed=rss2) supplies subscribers with a method to remain knowledgeable in regards to the newest information, publications, and different bulletins from the positioning.
