In New York City, Mamdani’s New Appointee Talks About Reimagining Public Safety

That is The Marshall Challenge’s Closing Argument publication, a weekly deep dive right into a key felony justice difficulty. Need this delivered to your inbox? Join future newsletters.

New York Metropolis Mayor Zohran Mamdani lately signed an government order creating the Workplace of Neighborhood Security, and appointed Deputy Mayor Renita Francois as its chief. The brand new workplace has authority over crime and violence prevention initiatives, neighborhood psychological well being companies, and victims’ help. In a press convention, Mamdani vowed that the workplace could be the important thing to “decrease crime and make New York protected.”

The workplace is Mamdani’s try to satisfy one of many central concepts that fueled his mayoral marketing campaign — however it’s additionally a pared-down model. With out laws from the Metropolis Council, the brand new workplace lacks the facility and permanence wanted to satisfy a number of the mayor’s sweeping objectives, and it might simply get scrapped by the following mayor. There’s additionally the difficulty of cash. Amid the town’s ongoing funds disaster, the OCS is ready to function in 2026 with $260 million — a far cry from the $1.1 billion Mamdani proposed on the marketing campaign path.

I spoke to Francois about her new place. Our dialog has been edited for size and readability.

Are you able to inform me a bit about your life earlier than working in authorities?

I grew up in Los Angeles within the ‘80s and ‘90s, when there was only a lot occurring… the warfare on medication, gang violence… all set in opposition to the backdrop of racial unrest with the [police] beating of Rodney King. However me and my siblings had entry to enrichment applications and issues that assist susceptible households keep steady, reminiscent of federal diet and housing help. These helped my mother, a working girl, afford life in Los Angeles. And that is what we would like right here for the folks of New York. We would like the folks to know that they will rely upon us for the assist that they should stabilize their households. And that is why we’re taking this ‘entire authorities’ strategy to neighborhood security.

That could be a robust proposition at a time when many individuals don’t belief the federal government to unravel issues as important as security.

I’ve seen that. My sister was usually suspicious of the healthcare system. She turned to quite a lot of pure cures. And when she was in a dire scenario with an ectopic being pregnant, which is one thing that’s survivable, she didn’t entry the healthcare system [that could have saved her life]. There are such a lot of folks like her who will not be reaching for care that’s proper there as a result of they do not belief that the system will be capable to assist them in the best way that they want. And that is a vital side of the Workplace of Neighborhood Security. We shall be working to construct that belief with communities in order that they will entry our important sources round issues like psychological well being.

You labored in then-Mayor Invoice de Blasio’s administration, overseeing the Mayor’s Motion Plan (MAP) for Neighborhood Security, which was launched in 2014 to cut back violence close to public housing. Is the work you’re set to do with OCS an extension of the belongings you did then?

MAP was actually about centering the wants of the general public and responding to what communities say would make them really feel and be protected. For some folks, meaning getting access to wholesome meals. For others, meaning having profession coaching or entry to some kind of profit that the federal government offers. We introduced sources from metropolis corridor down into the neighborhood and tried to make a powerful reference to residents who’ve been missed for a lot too lengthy. I feel that is actually foundational for OCS.

Mamdani’s marketing campaign generated pleasure across the thought of a Division of Neighborhood Security, which might have required the Metropolis Council to go laws. As an alternative, his government order created an workplace, which wields much less energy. How do you see this iteration of his general imaginative and prescient?

Our objective is to be a full-on division, and it is going to be a full-on division. The mayor mentioned, and I’ve mentioned, that is only a first step. Tons of metropolis companies have began out like this. Should you have a look at the [city’s] Workplace of Emergency Administration, or the Division of Homeless Companies, this is similar strategy that they took. We’re following a longtime course of.

In line with the NYPD, 2025 was New York’s most secure 12 months with regard to gun violence. There have been 668 taking pictures incidents, which was 10% fewer than in 2018, the final 12 months with the bottom quantity of incidents. Why does the town even must create an Workplace of Neighborhood Security?

There are a selection of stakeholders that may be credited with us having the protected 12 months that we have had, such because the disaster administration system, which exists alongside the regulation enforcement infrastructure. These numerous stakeholders play a task in holding communities protected. However we additionally wish to be proactive. We have seen “most secure years” earlier than, together with once I was in Mayor de Blasio’s workplace. The purpose is to maintain it going, to not wait round for one thing to occur after which react. One younger particular person dropping their life is simply too many.

I spoke lately with Sheina Banatte, the managing director of Justice for Eudes. Her cousin, Eudes Pierre, was shot by the NYPD in 2021 whereas he was experiencing a psychological well being disaster. Banatte is conscious that the OCS is in search of to broaden sufferer companies within the metropolis, however what’s going to it supply the individuals who’ve been harmed by the police?

That is a very good query, and it is one of many actually arduous questions that we have to carry people collectively to consider. I empathize with Sheina and her household. I am sorry for it, however I feel that there’s a possibility for us to actually hear from individuals who have had an expertise like Sheina and be taught from them about what their expectations could be round how the town can greatest assist them heal. Our regulation enforcement companions may also find out how we needs to be responding to these kinds of points. The Workplace of Neighborhood Security is supporting applications like B-Heard as a result of we wish to be sure that regulation enforcement shouldn’t be the only responder to people who’re in psychological well being disaster.

New York first launched B-Heard in 2021. As an alternative of solely sending cops to folks in disaster, this system is meant to dispatch psychological well being professionals. Mamdani needs an expanded B-Heard. However in response to a metropolis audit, between 2022 and 2024 B-Heard groups typically didn’t arrive, and didn’t reply to 35% of calls they may have been dispatched to. Why maintain pushing this program, if it has failed to satisfy objectives?

Everybody can agree that B-Heard has been underutilized and underfunded. The dedication of this administration is to actually put money into alternate responses in an actual approach that we have not finished earlier than. The objective is to construct capability in order that it is a viable response. It is about scaling up. It is about enhancing this system. And I will not fake to know every little thing. I have never even began the job, however I am trying ahead to coming along with the oldsters who try this work, who comprehend it greatest. However I do know that the dedication of this administration is to put money into an actual approach in order that we now have the flexibility to really reply.

How do you get different departments and stakeholders throughout the town to purchase in on this new workplace and the choice methods you are attempting to deal with felony justice and security?

If you wish to go quick, go alone. And if you wish to go far, go collectively. So after all, we’re positively going to be doing the work to put strong partnerships throughout the town, as a result of security actually is inclusive. With [de Blasio’s] MAP program, we labored with a ton of company companions who needed to do issues in a brand new approach. For instance, we had the Division for the Growing old and their kinship caregiver program as part of MAP. That program was for grandparents who have been parenting for a second time. We supported households who’re in that scenario to be extra linked to their younger folks. So we have finished this type of factor earlier than.

Are there any belongings you’ve seen across the nation that you just’re enthusiastic about and wish to discover in NYC?

[I]n Richmond, California, [there] is a neighborhood violence intervention program that’s evidence-based. It is one thing that we may very well be doing. I do know we now have the disaster administration system program, however that is actually targeted on coaching and workforce improvement. It offers technical help to the oldsters who’re doing the CVI work and for the general public sector companions like us. And it is only a completely different tackle gun violence prevention. Of us are doing loads of good work like that in Albuquerque, Denver, Newark, Baltimore.

There’s a lot curiosity across the Mamdani administration, I think about lots of people shall be trying to you and what you do as they think about creating their very own Places of work of Neighborhood Security.

Once I was the manager director of MAP, we received a lot outreach, even from locations so far as New Zealand. It’s at all times an trade. We are going to be taught from them as they’ve realized from us and vice versa. And I feel that that is the best way ahead, not only for New York, however for the nation.