Filed
12:00 p.m. EDT
03.21.2026
Analysis reveals folks typically “age out” of crime, and well being care prices are ballooning. However nonetheless, many states oppose releasing aged prisoners.
An incarcerated man sits in his wheelchair, studying a newspaper in his cell block at California State Jail, Solano in Vacaville, California, in 2013.
That is The Marshall Undertaking’s Closing Argument publication, a weekly deep dive right into a key prison justice difficulty. Need this delivered to your inbox? Join future newsletters.
On Wednesday, the California Board of Parole Hearings voted to reevaluate its earlier determination to grant “aged parole” to Gregory Vogelsang. The 57-year-old has served 27 years of what’s primarily a life sentence for sexually assaulting younger kids.
The transfer comes amid a broader political backlash over a state regulation that enables some incarcerated folks to change into eligible for parole primarily based on age and time served. The controversy first ignited final month round David Allen Funston, a 64-year-old convicted of sexual abuse of kids. He was scheduled for launch on aged parole earlier than authorities as a substitute transferred him from state jail to a county jail, the place he was arrested on newly revived costs tied to an alleged 1996 abuse case. Funston has pleaded not responsible.
The 2 circumstances have fueled bipartisan efforts to restrict such releases below the California regulation, together with proposals to lift the minimal age as excessive as 75 for some crimes, and to exclude folks convicted of sure crimes in opposition to kids from being thought-about for aged parole.
Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom has defended the regulation in broad strokes, however mentioned Wednesday that he disagreed with the parole board’s determination within the Vogelsang and Funston circumstances, and was open to tighter scrutiny of the aged parole system.
In California, elder parole started in 2014, when the state was below stress to cut back its jail inhabitants after years of courtroom intervention over unconstitutional circumstances. The state is considered one of 23, plus the District of Columbia, with an aged parole statute, in response to a 2024 evaluation by the Nationwide Convention of State Legislatures. The legal guidelines have emerged partially in recognition that folks typically “age out” of crime as they grow old, and partially as a response to the excessive medical prices and logistical challenges — like getting wheelchairs via a safe facility — that growing older prisoners create.
This week, The Attraction supplied a gutting instance of how this could play out. When alarms sound in California prisons, older folks could also be ordered to drop to the ground or stand in place for as much as an hour — a painful selection for somebody with arthritis, plantar fasciitis and different mobility points.
Again in 2014, California’s elder parole thresholds utilized to folks 60 and older who had served no less than 25 years — in step with most different states with related legal guidelines. In 2020, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, lawmakers lowered the thresholds to 50-years-old and 20 years served in jail, as one of many lesser-noticed modifications in a collection of progressive justice reforms.
Fifty years outdated could sound like an odd definition of “aged” in a rustic the place age 65 is usually thought-about the brink for senior citizenship, but it surely displays a rising consensus in scientific literature that incarcerated folks age sooner than most of the people, a actuality that extends far past California. Earlier this month, two New Orleans males who spent a long time on the Louisiana State Penitentiary in Angola described coming residence with most cancers, glaucoma, Hepatitis C and different diseases — the gathered toll, advocates say, from years of stress and poor medical care. “Dudes, simply get outdated and die in there, man,” one of many males, who goes by Wee, informed The Lens.
In Louisiana, that actuality has helped drive a distinct dialog than the one raging in California. Whereas lawmakers within the Golden State debate whether or not outdated prisoners ought to have one other shot at life, in Louisiana, some are pushing for releases that may result in a extra dignified dying.
Louisiana state regulation permits for compassionate launch of prisoners when a physician says they’ve lower than 60 days to stay, however in lots of circumstances, by the point the state processes that paperwork, the particular person making use of has already died of their cell, in response to reporting this week by The Advocate. That has led to a legislative push to develop the window to these with 120 days left to stay, and it has attracted help from an unlikely coalition of justice reform advocates, corrections officers and Catholic clergy.
Pennsylvania’s compassionate launch regulation permits the discharge of individuals with lower than one yr to stay, and has led to simply 54 releases over the previous 15 years, in response to the Pennsylvania Capital-Star. A invoice pending earlier than the state Senate would lengthen launch not simply to dying prisoners, however to these with extreme useful impairment, cognitive decline and continual circumstances needing intensive medical therapy, as properly.
Lawmakers in New York, in the meantime, are weighing passage of an aged parole regulation just like the one in California. As proposed, it might enable folks 55 and older who’ve served no less than 15 years an opportunity to look earlier than the parole board. The trouble comes alongside a February report by state Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli, which discovered that the share of older folks behind bars has grown quickly for the reason that pandemic.
At this level, you is likely to be questioning why a comptroller — the federal government model of an accountant — is releasing research on the age of the state jail inhabitants. It’s not as odd because it might sound.
Whereas mercy is commonly a part of compassionate launch and elder launch conversations, price is rarely removed from the floor. Prisoners are the one folks within the nation who’re constitutionally assured medical therapy, and as they age, their healthcare prices change into a large legal responsibility for state governments. A Virginia Division of Corrections report from earlier this yr discovered that 9% of individuals incarcerated there accounted for 86% of the entire medical bills in 2024, with growing older cited as a key driver. Democratic lawmakers cited the excessive prices in passing a invoice to develop the state parole board final month, with a watch on releasing extra growing older prisoners. As soon as launched from jail, previously incarcerated folks usually change into eligible for Medicare or Medicaid.
However in Virginia, like in California, the worry of reoffense — even when statistically unlikely — creates profound resistance for these sorts of launch efforts, no matter price financial savings. “Prison justice will not be low cost, and we’re not going to compromise the protection of our communities throughout the commonwealth of Virginia, our neighborhoods, our households,” Republican State Senator Mark Obenshain informed Courthouse Information.
In Texas, an analogous safety-at-all-costs logic undergirds a little-known nook of the state’s authorized system, the place worry of reoffense retains some folks confined even after they’ve accomplished their sentences.
This week, the Houston Chronicle reported on the state’s civil dedication workplace, which holds folks convicted of intercourse crimes when they’re deemed to have a “psychological abnormality” that makes their conduct uncontrollable. The U.S. Supreme Courtroom allowed this sort of dedication in a 1997 determination.
The inhabitants is outdated by design, since all of these admitted are coming off lengthy jail sentences, and in contrast to prisoners serving prison sentences, these in civil dedication aren’t eligible for compassionate launch. In accordance with the Chronicle, this system spent $7.2 million on medical care in 2025 after budgeting simply $1.8 million. Of the greater than 700 males (and one lady) who’ve been admitted for the reason that program started in 2015, solely 30 have ever been launched.
“They are saying it’s rehabilitation,” Gene Anthes, an Austin lawyer, informed the Chronicle. “However that’s bull. It’s a chance to lock them up and throw away the important thing.”
