‘No MAGA Left Behind’: How Trump’s Pardons Differ from Past Presidents

Filed
12:00 p.m. EDT

05.31.2025

The president has remade the pardons course of with seemingly one key precept in thoughts: “No MAGA left behind.”

That is The Marshall Undertaking’s Closing Argument publication, a weekly deep dive right into a key prison justice problem. Need this delivered to your inbox? Join future newsletters.

Over the previous two weeks, President Donald Trump has issued a wave of pardons and sentence reductions to dozens of political allies, marketing campaign donors, legislation enforcement officers, and Republican politicians, amongst others. The strikes mark a decisive departure from early-term clemency choices by prior administrations, and seem to observe a transparent precept: “No MAGA left behind.”

That pithy flip of phrase originates with Ed Martin, a right-wing political operative and Trump ally who now leads the president’s clemency efforts. Martin was appointed to run the Justice Division’s Workplace of the Pardon Legal professional after failing to win Senate affirmation because the U.S. Legal professional for Washington, D.C. Some Republican senators expressed discomfort with Martin’s shut ties to the Jan. 6 rebel and its contributors, and didn’t assist his bid for the function.

Martin was ceremonially sworn in on Wednesday, marking a dramatic change to the character of the pardons’ workplace. For greater than a century, profession civil servants led the workplace, evaluating clemency petitions and making suggestions to the president primarily based on authorized and humanitarian standards.

“The thought is to make sure that the president is receiving impartial and non-political recommendation about using his clemency energy,” Liz Oyer, the pardon lawyer earlier than Martin, mentioned on Reveal’s podcast, Extra To The Story, final week. Trump fired Oyer in March, hours after she refused to advance a pardon for actor Mel Gibson’s 2011 home violence conviction. Gibson is an in depth pal of Trump’s, and the president personally requested the pardon in order that Gibson might regain his proper to personal a firearm, in accordance with Oyer.

“That is not one thing that was within the atypical scope of my duties, neither is it one thing that I might do as a result of I merely did not have sufficient info,” Oyer defined throughout the interview with Reveal.

The usage of presidential clemency to learn political allies and private acquaintances just isn’t new. Presidents have the constitutional authority to negate (pardon) or shorten (commute) any federal conviction or sentence as they see match. And presidents from each events have lengthy used this energy for a number of self-serving pardons, usually on the finish of their phrases. That included unprecedented pardons issued by Joe Biden for his members of the family late final yr.

Traditionally, these acts of clemency have functioned in parallel with — and distinctly other than — the broader work of the pardon workplace, which might perform as a “security valve” for extreme sentences. Martin’s appointment appears to sign an finish to that separation, nevertheless.

In what has grow to be a theme of the second Trump administration, the partisan overhaul of the pardons’ workplace represents a extra aggressive and bombastic model of efforts throughout Trump’s first time period. In 2021, a pair of authorized students concluded that Trump’s clemency choices bypassed the pardon’s lawyer extra usually than any president in historical past.

The current swell of clemency exercise displays this new route. Amongst these granted clemency this month had been Todd and Julie Chrisley, actuality tv stars who had been convicted in 2022 of tax evasion and defrauding banks of greater than $30 million.

Their daughter, Savannah Chrisley, had been a vocal advocate for his or her launch, showing on “My View with Lara Trump” — hosted by the president’s daughter-in-law — and talking on the 2024 Republican Nationwide Conference.

Past politics, the Chrisleys’ pardons align with Trump’s longstanding fascination with actuality tv, superstar and bodily look. “You guys don’t seem like terrorists to me,” Trump mentioned of the household, in accordance with the youthful Chrisley.

Trump additionally pardoned Scott Jenkins, a Virginia sheriff sentenced earlier this yr to 10 years in jail for taking greater than $75,000 in bribes in alternate for handing out deputy badges to marketing campaign donors and different associates untrained in legislation enforcement. This pardon matches into Trump’s broader sample of eliminating and reversing federal efforts to carry legislation enforcement accountable for misconduct.

In some instances, clemency has delivered not simply freedom, however important monetary advantages. When Trump pardoned Paul Walczak, a Florida nursing house government convicted of evading almost $11 million in payroll taxes, the choice eradicated almost $4.4 million in court-ordered restitution to the U.S. authorities. The Chrisleys, equally, are actually doubtlessly exempt from any of the but unpaid $17 million in restitution they owed.

Walczak’s pardon got here after his mom attended a $1 million-per-plate fundraiser on the president’s Mar-a-Lago resort. The New York Instances reported that Walczak’s clemency utility included lengthy sections boasting of his mom’s in depth political donations to Republicans, and of her efforts to publish the non-public diary of Joe Biden’s daughter Ashley.

The Trump administration has not commented on each single pardon, however has typically defended the choices by arguing that political allies who’ve acquired pardons had been unfairly focused by Democrat-appointed prosecutors.

A few of Trump’s current acts of clemency have much less apparent political salience, together with a commutation for Chicago gang chief Larry Hoover on conspiracy, drug trafficking and different prices, in addition to a pardon for the Louisiana rapper NBA YoungBoy on gun prices. Whereas Hoover has been a pet trigger for Trump ally Ye (previously Kanye West), neither man has clear private or political connections to the president. On social media, some have seen Trump’s transfer as a cynical plot to ingratiate himself and the broader MAGA motion with Black males.

In any occasion, each are fairly well-known — or maybe notorious in Hoover’s case. That’s not true of most clemency candidates. As of final month, the pardon lawyer had a backlog of almost 8,000 clemency petitions, many from folks serving lengthy sentences for nonviolent offenses. With the workplace seemingly now centered on the president’s allies and massive names, it stays to be seen whether or not these different candidates will ever obtain a severe overview.