Filed
12:00 p.m. EDT
04.19.2025
America’s experiment with Scandinavian-inspired jail models is rising — and being examined.
Two folks play chess within the “Little Scandinavia” unit on the State Correctional Establishment-Chester in 2023 in Chester, Pa.
That is The Marshall Challenge’s Closing Argument e-newsletter, a weekly deep dive right into a key felony justice challenge. Need this delivered to your inbox? Subscribe to future newsletters.
When most individuals image U.S. prisons, they don’t normally think about inexperienced crops, vibrant murals, wood furnishings, cuddly canine or fish tanks. In most services, they’d be proper.
However at SCI Chester, a medium-security jail exterior Philadelphia, a small pilot unit often known as “Little Scandinavia” is testing whether or not that sort of atmosphere, modeled on the prisons of Nordic international locations like Norway and Denmark, can’t solely change how prisons look, but additionally how they work.
The unit, opened in 2022, was created by way of a partnership between the state corrections division, Drexel College and the College of Oslo in Norway. Its premise is straightforward, if radical, by U.S. requirements: Prisons ought to primarily deal with making ready folks to efficiently reenter society — reasonably than on punishment.
Final month, Pennsylvania corrections Secretary Laurel Harry introduced that the state would increase its Scandinavian-inspired method to a few new services. The transfer got here after a randomized research at SCI Chester confirmed promising early outcomes. The unit has seen only a single bodily altercation since opening, and based on Harry, workers have reported a higher “sense of goal.”
“It’s a complete completely different vibe,” one man incarcerated within the unit informed Penn Dwell final yr. “It’s extra of a group.” Officers within the unit are skilled to behave extra as mentors than as guards, and other people incarcerated there are inspired to construct casual relationships with workers in methods which are usually in opposition to the foundations or norms in typical jail environments.
California, in the meantime, is pushing forward with a extra financially formidable imaginative and prescient for Nordic-inspired jail reform. Whereas the 64-bed Chester unit value Pennsylvania simply $310,000 to arrange, California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s administration is spending almost 1 / 4 of a billion {dollars} to remake San Quentin State Jail right into a Scandinavian-style “rehabilitation heart” to accommodate upwards of two,500 folks. The rebranded facility will embody vocational coaching hubs, a podcast studio, a farmer’s market and a self-serve grocery retailer. Development has already begun at San Quentin, and the unit is scheduled to open in January. The brand new facility represents a flashy centerpiece in a broader, system-wide shift towards rehabilitation, dubbed “the California Mannequin.”
Response to the San Quentin mission has been combined. One of the vital outspoken critics of the hassle has been Steve Brooks, an incarcerated journalist on the jail. He wrote that even at its finest, the redesign wouldn’t scale to California’s huge jail system or meaningfully have an effect on most individuals inside it. Brooks argued the state ought to as an alternative be targeted on closing prisons and reinvesting the financial savings “in the direction of reentry applications, job coaching, housing help, training grants, psychological well being help, substance abuse remedy and extra,” a place echoed by some jail abolitionists when the query of Nordic-style prisons comes up.
Earlier this month, Brooks claimed in a private essay that his writing questioning the hassle in the end value him his job as editor-in-chief of the San Quentin Information.
Some victims’ rights teams have additionally come out in opposition to the hassle, arguing that the state ought to as an alternative spend the cash on victims’ companies. The efforts have cut up conservative observers, with some accusing liberal politicians of “placing criminals forward of law-abiding residents,” and others expressing help. Noting that 95% of individuals in jail are in the end launched, columnist Steven Greenhut reasoned earlier this month: “If somebody from San Quentin moved into your neighborhood, would you need that particular person to have spent the previous 10 years combating for his life as a part of a skinhead gang or somebody who had spent the time attending courses, gardening, and taking part in ping pong?”
The state correctional union has supplied guarded help for the adjustments, regardless of the hesitation of the state’s correctional workers. Final week, the Sacramento Bee reported that workers buy-in stays the “largest impediment” to the rollout. Some corrections officers have alleged that the brand new freedoms awarded to incarcerated folks “created extra harmful conditions.”
Different officers see main promise within the new California method. Officer Richard Kruse informed the Los Angeles Occasions final summer season that he was “stoked” concerning the adjustments and embraced a task on San Quentin’s “useful resource workforce” to assist with the supposed cultural shift. Kruse has embraced board and video video games as a software for modeling social conduct. “They’re gonna go away sometime. That’s going to be your neighbor, is perhaps your member of the family’s neighbor,” Kruse informed the Occasions. “These guys, if I can work with [them] to make [them] higher, that, to me, is what it’s about.”
In Connecticut — dwelling to a different small-scale Nordic reform effort — supporters of the method recommend {that a} extra humane atmosphere may have materials advantages for corrections officers. “You’re doing this for the incarcerated, however you’re additionally doing this to your colleagues,” coach Kevin Reeder says he tells skeptical officers, who discover it arduous to shake the assumption that jail “ought to really feel like a jail.” Reeder works with the nonprofit Amend, one of many major teams pushing to combine these sorts of fashions in U.S. prisons. He reminds the trainees that “they, too, do time” within the facility and that the tough, unforgiving atmosphere could contribute to the career’s excessive charges of PTSD, despair, and suicide and shortened life expectancy.
However even within the international locations that impressed these reforms, sustaining them has confirmed troublesome. Understaffing in Norway’s prisons has led to folks being locked of their cells for as much as 22 hours a day, and the suspension of programming whereas workers is reassigned to protect obligation. Danish prisons, in the meantime, are over capability thanks partly to new, longer sentences for some violent crimes, based on researcher Kaigan Carrie, writing for The Dialog.
“The Nordic international locations nonetheless present a supply of inspiration concerning their smaller jail populations and extra humane approaches to imprisonment,” Carrie concludes. “However as political beliefs on crime and punishment evolve, they’re clearly not immune from the issues” dealing with jail techniques around the globe.
