Viktor Orbán meets Vladimir Putin despite EU outcry

Unlock the Editor’s Digest without spending a dime

Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly e-newsletter.

Viktor Orbán met Russian President Vladimir Putin in Moscow on Friday, prompting an outcry from his EU and Nato allies who warned that the Hungarian prime minister didn’t signify them.

The unannounced journey is a stark demonstration of Orbán’s place as one of many west’s most pro-Russian leaders, in what officers stated breached diplomatic protocol and undermined EU and Nato unity.

Orbán, whose nation took over the rotating EU presidency on Monday, arrived in Russia simply days after a shock journey to Kyiv — his first since Putin ordered the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, in an obvious effort to dealer peace between the 2 sides.

Talking to reporters within the Kremlin after the three-hour assembly with Putin, Orbán stated he had realised Ukraine and Russia’s stances had been “very removed from each other”.

Putin demanded a “full and last finish to the battle”, which he stated required Ukraine to give up 4 of its jap provinces to Russia. Russia additionally had “different circumstances”, Putin stated, which have beforehand included a requirement that Ukraine pledges by no means to affix Nato.

Ukraine has stated Putin’s phrases quantity to capitulation and would go away the nation susceptible to additional assaults.

Orbán stated he would proceed to work on a doable finish to the warfare through the six months his nation holds the EU’s presidency.

“There are nearly no international locations left which might be in touch with each side. Hungary is one in every of them.”

However a number of EU leaders careworn that they’d not mandated the Hungarian premier to talk on their behalf, a place additionally underlined by Nato’s management.

German Chancellor Olaf Scholz on Friday stated Orbán was in Moscow not as a consultant of the rotating EU presidency however as Hungarian PM. Scholz stated the EU’s perspective was clear: “We condemn the Russian warfare of aggression.”

The Kremlin stated Hungary had first recommended the assembly on Wednesday after Orbán’s go to to Kyiv, the place he met Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy.

Hungary knowledgeable Nato of the Moscow journey upfront, however not the EU. When EU leaders tried to succeed in him on Thursday night, they had been rebuffed by Budapest, folks aware of the tried conversations stated.

“It was not a dialogue . . . it was my employees being knowledgeable by his employees,” stated Jens Stoltenberg, Nato secretary-general. “He doesn’t signify Nato.”

“I anticipate Hungary to face by Nato choices that they’re a part of . . . making it completely clear that it’s Russia who’s chargeable for this warfare. Russia is the perpetrator,” he added.

On his technique to Moscow, Orbán acknowledged that he was not representing the EU.

“Hungary doesn’t have the mandate to barter on behalf of the European Union. I might by no means faux. However I can discover the scenario,” he stated.

Orbán’s journey is the primary by an EU chief to Russia since Austrian Chancellor Karl Nehammer visited Moscow in April 2022 in a failed try and persuade Putin to finish the warfare.

The EU’s outgoing high diplomat, Josep Borrell, on Friday stated Orbán’s go to to Moscow was an “solely” bilateral one. Estonian Prime Minister and the bloc’s decide as Borrell’s successor, Kaja Kallas, stated on X that Orbán “is exploiting the EU presidency place to sow confusion.”

An EU diplomat informed the Monetary Instances that “with such a gathering the Hungarian presidency ends earlier than it has actually begun” and that the “scepticism of EU member states was sadly justified — it’s all about selling Budapest’s pursuits”.

Hungary holding the rotating EU presidency means Orbán’s ministers are answerable for chairing the bloc’s conferences — however the premier has no formal illustration function.

Beneficial

European Council president Charles Michel, who represents the bloc’s 27 leaders, was the primary to publish on X on Thursday that Orbán was not talking on behalf of the EU.

Regardless of his current overture to Kyiv, which included three hours of talks with Zelenskyy, Orbán has constantly taken a pro-Russia stance since 2022, delaying EU sanctions on Moscow and opposing help to Kyiv.

Orbán was additionally the primary western chief to fulfill Putin at a convention in China final October after the Worldwide Legal Courtroom issued an arrest warrant for warfare crimes allegedly perpetrated by the Russian chief.

Daniel Hegedűs, a political analyst with German Marshall Fund, a think-tank, stated these first few days had already proven what the EU can anticipate from Hungary’s six-month presidency: “disruption, instability and trolling”.

“The Moscow go to is being framed as an endeavour by Orbán to mediate Russia’s warfare of aggression in Ukraine, however nobody sees the hassle as honest or reputable,” Hegedűs stated.

Extra reporting by Man Chazan in Berlin and Christopher Miller in Kyiv